Harris Poll: Americans Balk at Lifetime SCOTUS Appointments
on October 05, 2014
12 Comments
A new poll from Harris Interactive suggests that 70% of Americans are uncomfortable with using a system of lifetime appointments to fill vacancies on our nation's highest Court.
This shouldn't come as a shock, and neither should that fact that millennials are far less likely to object to the idea of lifetime appointments (only 63% object) as compared to baby boomers (73%), "matures" (76%), and---perhaps most interestingly---Gen Xers (71%.)
A generational gap isn't surprising because, for all intents and purposes, the Court is generally painted as some sort of next-level legislative body, expected to respond to the ever-fluid world views of pundits, protesters, and various voting demographics. (Don't believe me? Review the news coverage from the Court's rejection of DOMA.) As a card-carrying member of the bizarro generation tucked neatly between "GenX" and "Millennial," I can testify to the fact that as we grow, so grows our exposure to various ideas about how government should respond to a diversifying society, and vice versa.
The problem with this viewpoint isn't that it's likely to change the system overnight---this would require a Constitutional amendment---but that it comes from a bloc of people who harbor a fundamental misunderstanding of the point and purpose of a Supreme Court.
The Harris Poll asked Americans to deliberate on the nation's highest court, and found that despite two-thirds of Americans (68%) feeling it's a crucial governing body for the success of the United States, nearly half of Americans (47%, up from 42% in 2010) say they are not knowledgeable about the Supreme Court confirmation process. Just over half of Americans (53%, down from 58% in 2010) indicate being that they're knowledgeable about the process, with one in ten (11%) saying specifically that they are very knowledgeable about it and just over four in ten (42%) saying they're somewhat knowledgeable.Less than half of those who have an opinion about how the court should be run know how we currently choose justices. Excellent. Then there's this gem:







