An anonymous group calling itself the Mapping Project has created an elaborate interconnected map of Jewish community leaders and groups who, like the vast majority of American Jews, support Israel. The Map implicitly serves as a target list, leading to widespread condemnation.
The Mapping Project’s self-described “multi-generational collective of activists and organizers” runs a website purporting to connect pro-Israel Jewish billionaires – and any Jewish (and non-Jewish) institutions to which they donate – to oppression of Palestinians and of minorities in the U.S. As the website’s title suggests, it maps the locations of these supposed Jewish “oppressors” and lists specific addresses.
The Mapping Project offers its own version of Orwellian Newspeak, twisting language into its opposite. According to the Mapping Project,
Nearly all Jewish organizations are Israel supporters and therefore are guilty of being “Zionist”, therefore supporters of colonialist supremacy. In other words, Jews who support Israel are guilty. They are Bad. What’s worse, their tentacles are everywhere.
Lest there be any doubt, the Mapping Project is totally opposed to the very existence of the state of Israel. “Support for the continued existence of a colonial-settler state anywhere in historic Palestine, or for colonial-settlers continuing to hold land there – whether on land colonized through various processes before 1948, land on which a settler-state was declared in 1948, or on land under occupation and colonization since 1967 – is Zionism,” i.e., white-supremacist colonialism.
The project’s priorities are as distant from reality as those of other contemporary left-wing movements like “defund the police,” and of “reform”-minded district attorneys like the recalled Chesa Boudin. For example, a Mondoweiss article authored in the name of the Mapping Project repeatedly condemned policing but referred to crime only as a made-up excuse for criminalizing protest movements. The reality of violent crime – not to mention theft and other lawbreaking – is completely lost on the project’s authors.
The Mondoweiss article hysterically describes police counterterrorism actions after 9/11 and after the Boston Marathon bombing as nothing more than “militarized violence” designed to oppress rights protestors. It says nothing about actual terrorist violence, except to deny the malevolence of terrorists like Usaamah Rahim and David Wright, who plotted to behead police officers and Pamela Geller. In particular, the project denounces the ADL for its work connecting American police with their Israeli counterparts in order to learn from Israeli experience fighting terrorist violence, which many leftist anti-Semites have branded “deadly exchange.”
Exactly who is behind the project is a mystery. Its website does not identify any of the people working on it (or funding it). The article it placed in Mondoweiss was published under the byline “The Mapping Project” – again, no names.
BDS Boston tweeted an enthusiastic endorsement of the project. Its tweet was retweeted by the anti-Israel Jewish Voice for Peace in a subsequently-deleted post. It was also retweeted by Greater Boston Tenants Union, which in turn was retweeted by Massachusetts Peace Action.
Given BDS Boston’s lead role in publicizing the Mapping Project, and the latter’s subject matter, one wonders what exactly the former’s role is. Is the Mapping Project an astroturfing project of BDS Boston? Like the anti-Israel letters to Google and Amazon supposedly sent by “anonymous staffers,” but actually sent by anti-Israel groups including Jewish Voice for Peace and M Powerchange.org? The project’s timing coincides with BDS Boston’s ratcheting up its obnoxious behavior with a call to “dismantle” Boston’s Jewish community.
The Zionist Organization of America (ZOA), one of the organizations targeted by the project, has condemned the project as “targeting and promoting of violence against American Jews and Jewish schools, charitable organizations and other institutions” in a letter to US Attorney General Merrick Garland and FBI head Christopher Wray. The letter urges them to “investigate and monitor all these antisemitic hate groups and their leaders, and to prosecute them consistent with the evidence and the law.” It adds, “Law enforcement needs to ensure that Jews and Jewish institutions in the Boston area and around the United States are safe and fully protected.” The Boston Herald reported that the FBI was looking into the website, but added, “At this time, we have not observed any direct threats of violence in open sources related to this map as of its publication.”
The ADL’s website explains the project’s anti-Semitism:
The ADL was been prominently targeted by the Mapping Project. ADL leader Jonathan Greenblatt condemned it in an op-ed. As per usual with him, he could not resist the temptation to bash “far-right extremism” as “singularly lethal,” even as he grudgingly acknowledged that the “organized anti-Zionist movement” is “no less conspiratorial and antisemitic.” The ADL also forwarded a tweet from its local New England chapter condemning the project.
Several congressional representatives have condemned the project for spreading anti-Semitism. They include Sens. Elizabeth Warren (D-Mass.), Ed Markey (D-Mass.) (both of whom are listed on the website – here and here), and Brian Schatz (D-HI), as well as Reps. Lee Zeldin (R-N.Y.), Jake Auchincloss (D-Mass.), Seth Moulton (D-Mass.), Ritchie Torres (D-N.Y.), and Carolyn Maloney (D-N.Y.). Rep. Ayanna Pressley (D-Mass.) also condemned the map. Although she is a member of the “Squad”, which is highly critical of Israel and at least one of whose members – Rep. Ilhan Omar (D-Minn.) – has made openly anti-Semitic remarks, and despite having been endorsed by Massachusetts Peace Action which is promoting the map, Pressley has previously broken with the Squad and stood up to anti-Semitism, as when she supported a resolution opposing the Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions movement (BDS). State Sen. Jason Lewis (D-Fifth Middlesex) also condemned the project.
The Mapping Project offers a fine illustration of Rabbi Lord Jonathan Sacks’ comment that anti-Semitism mutates. Whatever society considers most objectionable, not to say loathsome, is projected onto Jews. Anti-Semitism:
takes different forms in different ages. In the Middle Ages, Jews were hated because of their religion. In the nineteenth and early twentieth century they were hated because of their race. Today they are hated because of their nation state, the state of Israel. It takes different forms but it remains the same thing: the view that Jews have no right to exist as free and equal human beings.
Its mutating nature is part of the reason for the lag time in appreciating contemporary anti-Semitism for what it is. Today, it is very often expressed as hatred of Israel for all sorts of nonsensical reasons, and from there, to casting Israel supporters out of society. Get the irony: Jews were persecuted for centuries as outsiders, without having a state of their own to protect them. Now that they have a state of their own, that state is persecuted for existing.
But old forms of the virus haven’t disappeared. Jews are still frequently presented as super-rich individuals using their wealth to control the world. The Mapping Project has succeeded in weaving both of these strands – old and new anti-Semitism – together to underpin its map.
CLICK HERE FOR FULL VERSION OF THIS STORY
