Maricopa County, AZ, Election Vendor ‘Mistakenly’ Mails 3,126 Ballots Early
I’d shrug my shoulder if Maricopa County didn’t have so many past election problems.
Officials in Maricopa County, Arizona’s most populous county, admitted that Runbeck Election Services “mistakenly” sent out over 3,000 ballots six days before the scheduled mailing date.
That county should sound familiar. More on that later.
The ballots went to the correct voters:
PHOENIX, Arizona — On October 2, Runbeck Election Services informed the Maricopa County Recorder’s Office that it had mistakenly mailed 3,126 early ballots the previous day, six days before the scheduled October 7 mailing date. The premature mailing was not authorized by the Recorder’s Office, which was notified only after it occurred.
Runbeck’s error affected only the timing of the mailing. The correct ballots were mailed to the correct voters.
Upon consultation with the Maricopa County Attorney’s Office, it was determined that the ballots remain valid and do not need to be voided or reissued. Voters may complete and return them normally. Any ballots received before early voting begins will remain unopened and securely stored until processing begins.
No voters were adversely affected. Runbeck accepts responsibility for their error and will work with the MCRO to implement appropriate controls to prevent it from ever happening again.
STATEMENT ON RUNBECK EARLY BALLOT PRE-MAILING
PHOENIX, Arizona — On October 2, Runbeck Election Services informed the Maricopa County Recorder's Office that it had mistakenly mailed 3,126 early ballots the previous day, six days before the scheduled October 7 mailing date. The… pic.twitter.com/nQMSe356lS
— Maricopa County Recorder's Office (@RecordersOffice) October 4, 2026
“These 3,126 packets were processed separately from the primary mailing because they did not qualify for USPS automated mail processing,” Runbeck Election Services said. “Non-automation mail requires separate handling and processing before being presented to the USPS.”
Today, Runbeck Election Services (RES) issued the following statement to the media.
We requested that in the interest of transparency they also post the statement publicly; however, they refused.
The MCRO believes this is the wrong call, so we are posting it publicly for them. pic.twitter.com/CslKTPzotr
— Maricopa County Recorder's Office (@RecordersOffice) October 4, 2026
Let’s rewind to Tuesday, November 8, 2022. The midterms.
Maricopa County got new machines after a disastrous 2020 election, but they didn’t work.
An independent investigation ended a few months after the election. From 2023:
Back in November, after the election, officials said that issues were not because of a toner, but a fuser that caused precincts to change the heat settings.
For the most part, the report confirms the initial findings as election officials used a longer ballot with heavier paper which caused certain printers to not get hot enough to transfer ink to the paper. “The combined effect of the heavy paper, longer ballot, and intermittent burst of print demand pushed the printers to perform at the very edge of or past their capability so that any decrease in fuser performance in an individual printer could result in problems,” the report read.
According to the report, the investigative team organized printers into groups depending on if the printers were in vote centers with reported problems or not.
They found in their testing that one-in-four ballots were misread due to heat fuser issues with printers when the ballot-on-demand printer was used in a way similar to how it would have been on Election Day.
A few days later, the county admitted that officials still had hundreds of thousands of ballots to count.
Then there’s 2020. I doubt we all need a refresher on that:
- Fox News Settles Dominion Voting Systems Defamation Lawsuit for $787 Million
- Arizona Grand Jury Indicts Giuliani, Meadows, and Other Trump Allies in 2020 Election Probe
- Supreme Court Upholds Arizona Ballot Harvesting Restrictions
- Maricopa Co. releases new report on 2020 election
Trump already responded:
🚨 BREAKING: President Trump just RIPPED Maricopa County, AZ for sending out THOUSANDS of ballots in "error" before early voting even began
"Maricopa is a very, VERY dishonest county."
"They should be ASHAMED of themselves"
It wasn't an "error" — they simply got CAUGHT.… pic.twitter.com/Du2sRoCRXG
— Nick Sortor (@nicksortor) October 5, 2026
Donations tax deductible
to the full extent allowed by law.





Comments
Always Maricopa county
It would be wonderful not to hear any more news like this about Maricopa County.
But of course we will.
They have a reputation to maintain…
It’s past time to start holding everyone involved in elections ‘mistakes, errors, omissions’ criminally and civilly liable. Where there’s a statutory date set by the Legislature for X action to commence then any violation where ‘X’ was done before that date/time as specified by the statute is a violation. It would dang sure be a problem if the polls closed early or ballots received on time were rejected just because the folks receiving them didn’t have sufficient training, safeguards or supervision to prevent it. This should be the same.
First the company should be terminated and permanently banned from anything to do with elections/ballots both by company name, licence and very importantly by company employee list. Bar them individually and if hired by another company that company is barred automatically. Secondly put those directly responsible and the supervisors all the way up the company hierarchy to the CEO into handcuffs facing 3,126 separate counts, one for each ballot.
When we demand that elections are run honestly, transparently and 100% within the statutes set by the Legislature without exception or deviation, then vigorously and ruthlessly prosecute every undotted I or uncrossed T then maybe those responsible for our elections will begin to take their duties seriously.
I remember when I “mistakenly” drove eighty in a sixty, I tried to tell the cop it was a mistake but he wrote me a ticket and I still had to go to court.
As a citizen of this country I’m always paying for my mistakes.
And if the law had specified a penalty for jumping the gun on the mailing then this company would have to pay it. But the law doesn’t do that, and no harm has resulted, so what’s the big deal?
Add this issue to the list of screwups that Runbeck has promised “will never happen again.”
In all fairness, most items on the list have never happened again. But the list is eight feet long, single spaced, and there is no limit to the new and inventive screwups that Runbeck hasn’t yet committed.
They can’t help themselves not to cheat,
Why would they not qualify for USPS automated mailing? Explain in full detail what was going on with these ballots. Why should believe that 3126 is the true number? Show some proof. Inquiring minds would like to know.
Exactly. Those are my questions as well.
This is a somewhat informed guess. I used to deal with software that did ZIP and ZIP+4 determination, address validation/standardization, carrier route presort, and other address functions to get USPS discounts for mailings from an insurance company so I got some familiarity with the USPS mailing regs. It’s been a few years but I would suspect some combination of specified voter registration addresses not conforming to what the USPS thinks the mailing address should be so they need to be manually checked, and an insufficient number of letters for a given area to qualify for bulk mail handling (basically instead of handing the letters to the Post Office one at a time ala dropping them in a mailbox you give them bundles that have been presorted based on USPS distribution and sorting locations so they can deliver them directly to a distributing facility and skip a bunch of intermediate handling)
How come my side ain’t doin’ no election fraudin’? It seems like it should be an equal opportunity thing.
Republicans do sometime try cheating at elections, but they’re not very good at it, because the Dems have had a lot more practice. The Dems have developed and polished systems for cheating and not getting caught, which is why we will never know who “really” won the 2020 election. The stuff that Team Trump trumpeted was total amateur hour, the kind of thing that Reps might have tried if they were trying to cheat; that’s not how the Dems do things.
The actual Dem cheating was not detected, because it’s designed not to be detected; the only way we know it was there is because they went to so much trouble to rig the system so as not to detect fraud, and no one does that unless they’re expecting fraud to benefit them.
I meant to add: When Republicans do try it they usually get caught, because they’re not very good at it. And the Dems use the fact that the majority of those who get caught cheating are Republicans to “prove” that the balance of fraud is on the Republican side. This is of course a fallacy. The Dem cheating is much more pervasive and much worse, but overwhelmingly they don’t get caught because they know what they’re doing.
You should also note that in many jurisdictions, the rules are created so there is not an effective control to stop, or event detect, cheating.
As I said, “they went to so much trouble to rig the system so as not to detect fraud, and no one does that unless they’re expecting fraud to benefit them.”
I see it now! Yes, we are in agreement on that point.
President Trump should know that asking a Democrats to feel shame is a waste of time.
Would Runbeck Election Services please explain to me how these 3,126 election packets did not “qualify for USPS automate mail processing”, exactly. I would have thought that all election packets would be uniform in size, weight and manner of address and therefore all the election packets would be qualified for automated processing. But apparently not. So what makes these 3,126 election packets different from all the other election packets is what I’d like to know.
Continuing my comment from above, what they are likely talking about is preprinting the distribution barcode on envelopes and then presorting based on ZIP code to skip intermediate sorting sites. My best guess would be these are addresses that kicked out of an automated address verification check, like a misspelled a street address or a voter gave an address that the USPS software didn’t like, prior to the presort, or there weren’t enough ballots to qualify for bulk mailing sorting to a particular area.
That’s just stupid. In what way could this possibly benefit the Dems? Or the Reps for that matter? What possible difference does it make if someone got their ballot a little early? It’s not as if there’s some reason they’re likely to change their vote during that week.
Sending them out early give 6 extra days for their cheaters to work those ballots – fill them out for the mentally incompetent, collect them, sort them, and do whatever they need to do to wine. Extra time is valuable.
In addition to lawdocs’s comments, early access means they may have physical access to complete ballots earlier, and that extra time could be used to create ballots that look and feel like the real ones: shows things like the exact paper, printing and so on. In a mail-in system, getting hands on blank ballots is a necessary step to most forms of cheating.
Not guaranteed that this is happening, but just another item that fits patterns.
That’s just pure speculation. There’s literally nothing to indicate any such thing. It’s certainly stupid to assert that it benefits one side.
We certainly are speculating and do not, at this point, have any supporting evidence of intent. However, the action is still subject to the question, Cui bono?
And the best and most likely answer is that it benefits no one, and was therefore an honest mistake. There is no foundation for any other answer.
Lawdoc’s suggestion makes no sense, because it depends on them already having someone on the inside at this processing company, in which case they already had access to sample ballots. They would gain nothing by mailing some ballots early.
You mean, other than cover for an early release? Or that it is actually 3,000+ ballots that went out, and do we know to whom they were sent?
This may be just innocent mistake. We are speculating on potential motives and reasons. Given the past struggles with this county, I don’t think we should just assume that innocence here.
They still think we’re stupid, that’s for sure. Mailed out accidentally, on purposely, intentionally, crookedly, sneakily, deliberately IOW.
To what end?
Obtuse is not a good look, Milhouse. See lawdoc’s reply to you for an answer to your question.
People who usually want to cheat are always testing the system to see what they can get away with.
Noted above that sending out ballots early may facilitate fraudulent activity. The early release doesn’t prove fraudulent activity but certainly supports that inference.
It makes no sense. Either they have someone on the inside at this company or they don’t. If they do, then they already have a sample ballot to work with. If they don’t then they can’t have arranged for the early mailing.
In addition there must be something different about these 3000 packets that made them ineligible for automatic processing by USPS. So whatever is in them would not be representative of what’s in the standard packet that most postal voters will be getting. So getting early access to this unusual packet doesn’t help with forging the standard ballots.
I have been reliably informed that such things are un-possible.
No, you haven’t been.
Here in Maricopa county I’m reliably told it will take a month or more to count the ballots but that any close races that can’t be called early will all swing in one direction as usual so not to worry.
WOW – that “tilting at windmill” thing surely has Milhouse in an uproar today! He usually just pops in with one or two “researched laws” to argue the DEMOcrat points but today? Whew!! Looks like he’s trying to guide the issue into the “never mind – nothing to see” direction! I think this is a prime example of “hitting a nerve”! Just a simple “error” – AGAIN from Maricopa County! Where’s Sheriff Joe and why didn’t all these issue exist when he was in office? Seems like it wasn’t until he was “voted” out that the issues began. I’m sure Milhouse will have a rebuttal for this that makes it clear that it’s been the opposite until Sheriff Joe was removed!