Mamdani Wants More Time to Close Rikers, Makes Decrease in Prison Population a Top Priority

Fresh off his announcement earlier this week that he was disbanding the NYPD’s Strategic Response Group (SRG), which “specializes in counterterrorism but also responds to major crimes and mass demonstrations,” NYC Mayor Zohran Mamdani said Friday that he was pushing for a delay in the deadline to close the Rikers Island jail complex.

The current deadline, which was mandated in 2019 by the New York City Council and then-Mayor Bill de Blasio, is August 31, 2027. But due to delays, brought on in part by former Mayor Eric Adams’ reluctance to have it shut down, Mamdani has asked the city council to approve an extension to 2032:

On Friday, Mayor Zohran Mamdani pushed the complex’s end date by five years to 2032, acknowledging that the obstacles to closing Rikers by 2027 were insurmountable. Leaders of the City Council, whose approval is needed to change the date, support the change.

Mr. Mamdani said that years of inaction from his predecessor, Eric Adams, had partly forced the city’s hand in pushing back the closure date. He promised a renewed commitment to see through what city leaders have promised since 2017: an end to housing of pretrial detainees on Rikers, sometimes referred to as Torture Island.

During his press conference, Mamdani also unveiled a comprehensive plan to press forward on the closure:

The City will build four borough-based jails by 2032, beginning with Brooklyn in 2029; create hundreds of therapeutic beds for New Yorkers with serious mental health conditions and complex medical needs; invest $146 million next fiscal year in mental health care, substance use treatment, educational and vocational programming both inside jails and in communities as well as victim services; reduce pretrial detention and case delays; modernize the Department of Correction; and plan for the future reuse of the island.

When the original closure plan passed in 2019, the city council noted that the “jail population has declined from 11,000 in 2014 to about 7,000 today and is projected to be approximately 3,300 by 2026.”

Well, it’s not. The current population sits at around 6,600, meaning that to “safely” house 4,100 inmates in the new facilities, that number will have to be whittled down by about 2,500.

As part of his plan, Mamdani shared how they were going to try to make that happen:

A key part of the strategy is reducing the city’s jail population from roughly 6,600 people in custody to about 4,100.

The administration said that goal will require reducing pretrial detention, speeding up criminal case processing and expanding alternatives to incarceration. City officials also plan to create an interagency task force focused on addressing court delays that keep people awaiting trial in jail for extended periods.

Most of the investment is to make things more “comfortable” and convenient for inmates, their families, their attorneys, and correctional facility staff, while only a small amount (around $16 million of a budget that is in the 100s of millions of dollars) will go to victims’ services.

The ultimate goal is listed right on Mamdani’s “Close Rikers Strategy” website (bolded emphasis added by me):

The Close Rikers: Strategic Plan lays out the path to fulfill that promise and builds a criminal legal system rooted in safety, accountability and dignity. Public safety cannot be measured by the number of people behind bars. It must be measured by whether New Yorkers are safe in their homes and neighborhoods, whether they can access the services they need and whether government is meeting its responsibilities. The research is clear: an overreliance on detention does not make our communities safer. Time in jail can increase the likelihood of rearrest and pull New Yorkers away from their jobs, families and schools. That is why we are investing in community-based services, addressing delays in the courts and making sure that no New Yorker spends a day in jail longer than necessary.

Big Apple residents concerned about crime risks should closely monitor how the Mamdani administration goes about decreasing the Rikers population. Back in April 2020, during the COVID pandemic, 1,500 or so prisoners were released from NYC jails under “compassionate release” circumstances, as The New York Post reported at the time, and some of them went on to violently victimize and reoffend:

At least 50 of the 1,500 inmates cut loose amid fears of the spread of COVID-19 behind bars in recent weeks have already landed back in jail — and in some cases were set free yet again, according to police sources and records.The re-offenders — just over 3 percent of those released — include a Rikers Island inmate initially jailed for allegedly setting his girlfriend’s door on fire and choking her mother, who was released early only to return to the Bronx apartment and allegedly threaten to kill the whole family.Another prisoner who is accused of assaulting a Department of Homeless services officer and was later set free was arrested for punching an agency sergeant just two days after his release, records show.

The paper also revealed that most released under those “compassionate release” conditions (like health concerns due to pre-existing conditions, etc.) were in on minor or non-violent offenses, “but some 300 of them face violent felony charges.” Even more were released after that story was filed.

Former NYC police commissioner Bill Bratton also had thoughts:

Great response to the insanity of City Hall closing Rikers when the new high rise jails—if they ever are built—will only hold 3,500 inmates. Does any sane, rational person believe that in a city of over 8 million people there are only 3,500 criminals who need to be incarcerated?Talk about a disincentive for New York cops to try and keep this city safe. Add that to all the cop-hating legislation currently being proposed at City Hall and Albany, and you have the recipe for mass migration to Florida.

Count on it.

– Stacey Matthews has also written under the pseudonym “Sister Toldjah” and can be reached via X. –

Tags: Crime, Democratic Socialism, Democrats, Eric Adams, New York City, Socialism, Zohran Mamdani

CLICK HERE FOR FULL VERSION OF THIS STORY