Feds Open Investigation Into Brown Univ Over Security Failures, as Campus Police Chief Placed on Leave

Feds Open Investigation Into Brown Univ Over Security Failures, as Campus Police Chief Placed on Leave

As we have covered, Brown Universities handling of security before, during, and after the shooting murder of two students on December 12 is highly questionable at best.

When I appeared on Fox and Friends yesterday morning, I call for a federal investigation of Brown’s security protocols:

Just today it was revealed that a custodian claims to have warned the university about the suspicious person (the shooter) during the two weeks prior to the shooting.

Now the U.S. Department of Education has opened a formal investigation for possible violations of the Clery Act. From the Press Release:

Today, the U.S. Department of Education (the Department) announced it will conduct a program review of Brown University (Brown) in response to the December 13, 2025, shooting on its campus, which killed two students. The Department’s Office of Federal Student Aid (FSA) will investigate if Brown violated Section 485(f) of the Higher Education Act, otherwise known as the Jeanne Clery Campus Safety Act (Clery Act), which requires institutions of higher education to meet certain campus safety and security-related requirements as a condition of receiving federal student aid.

In the hours after the shooting, public reporting appeared to show that Brown’s campus surveillance and security system may not have been up to appropriate standards, allowing the suspect to flee while the university seemed unable to provide helpful information about the profile of the alleged assassin. Additionally, many Brown students and staff reported that the university’s emergency notifications about the active shooter were delayed, raising significant concerns about their safety alert system. If true, these shortcomings constitute serious breaches of Brown’s responsibilities under federal law.

“After two students were horrifically murdered at Brown University when a shooter opened fire in a campus building, the Department is initiating a review of Brown to determine if it has upheld its obligation under the law to vigilantly maintain campus security,” said U.S. Secretary of Education Linda McMahon. “Students deserve to feel safe at school, and every university across this nation must protect their students and be equipped with adequate resources to aid law enforcement. The Trump Administration will fight to ensure that recipients of federal funding are vigorously protecting students’ safety and following security procedures as required under federal law.”

As part of the review, FSA has requested that Brown submit information by January 30, 2026, including:

• Copies of the original 2024 and 2025 Annual Security Reports (ASRs), and any revised versions of these reports that were produced for the purpose of complying with the Clery Act, along with credible evidence of distribution and/or redistribution;
• An “audit trail” showing all incidents of crime (organized by offense classification) for the calendar years 2021-2024 and an “audit trail” showing all arrests made by Brown University Public Safety and Emergency Management Department (BPS) or other state or local law enforcement agencies, and all referrals for disciplinary action against students or employees for violations of state laws and local ordinances related to the illegal possession, use, and/or distribution of weapons, drugs, or liquor that were included in the statistical disclosures contained in the University’s 2024 and 2025 ASRs;
• A copy of the BPS’s activity/dispatch/call log for calendar years 2021-2025;
• A copy of the daily crime log for calendar years 2021-2025;
• A list of all Timely Warnings and Emergency Notifications issued by the university during calendar years 2021-2025, with a brief description of the means or media used to disseminate the notices;
• A copy of all of Brown’s policies and procedures, including any internal policies and procedures, related to timely warnings and emergency notifications, maintenance of a daily crime log, and emergency response notifications and evacuation, and a copy of any assessments of Brown’s campus safety policies and practices conducted since 2020; and
• A complete set of BPS’s standard operating procedures regarding dispatch, response to calls, reporting writing, arrests including issuance of citations, and protocols for active shooter scenarios.

The description of the investigation does not indicate whether it will look into whether Brown’s anti-police attitudes contributed to the security failure.

Meanwhile, the Brown police chief has been placed on leave according to Boston ABC5 and other outlets:

The Brown University chief of police has been placed on leave, effective immediately, university president Christina Paxson announced in a letter to the school community Monday.

Rodney Chatman, who also served as the Vice President for Public Safety and Emergency Management, was placed on leave over one week after a deadly shooting at the university’s Barus and Holley building left two students dead.

Hugh Clements will serve as chief of police and Vice President for Public Safety and Emergency Management in the interim. Clements was the Providence Chief of Police from 2011 to 2023.

As more facts come out, Brown’s handling of campus security will look worse and worse, and should result in more firings and resignations.

Donations tax deductible
to the full extent allowed by law.