Israel’s Supporters Respond with Prayer; Palestinians Celebrate
The IDF is conducting a massive manhunt for three Israeli teens kidnapped Thursday night. The three students Eyal Yifrah, 19, from Elad, Gil-Ad Shaer, 16, from Talmon and Naftali Frenkel, 16, from Nof Ayalon went missing as they were heading home from the Yeshiva where they were studying is Gush Etzion. (Gush Etzion or Etzion Bloc, is an area of Israel that illegally seized by Jordan in Israel’s 1948 War of Independence and recaptured by Israel in 1967.)
According to Avi Issacharoff of the Times of Israel, Israeli forces are focusing on two members of Hamas who live in the Hebron area and disappeared Thursday.
The working assumption by Palestinian intelligence is that Hamas is behind the kidnappings, a suspicion confirmed by Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu Sunday morning.
According to the Palestinian sources, Palestinian intelligence received notice of the kidnapping only 12 hours after the event, and since then has maintained communications with the Israeli side, with active coordination between the two security forces.
Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas, the sources said, is receiving regular updates on the situation’s latest developments, though they expressed consternation about Israel’s handling of the affair and Netanyahu’s castigating Abbas for signing a unity pact with Hamas.
While it appears that Abbas and the Palestinian Authority are cooperating with Israel in the search for the teens, Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu is holding the PA culpable for kidnapping.
“This morning I can say what I was unable to say yesterday before the extensive wave of arrests of Hamas members in Judea and Samaria.
Those who perpetrated the abduction of our youths were members of Hamas – the same Hamas that Abu Mazen made a unity government with; this has severe repercussions.
We are currently focusing all of our efforts on bringing the abductees back home. Before coming here, I spoke again with the families, and I embrace and encourage them from here, from the Cabinet table, and I know that I speak for all parts of the nation.”
While there are those who are absolving the PA for responsibility, an Israeli official told to the New York Times:
An Israeli government official, who spoke on the condition of anonymity because he was not authorized to discuss the issue publicly, defended Mr. Netanyahu’s stance. “Hamas has been directly responsible for countless kidnap attempts and murders of Israelis,” the official said. Now, he said, Mr. Abbas had formed a government on the basis of a signed agreement with Hamas, giving it legitimacy
and allowing it a presence in the West Bank.
“We know that one of the establishing principles of the Palestinian Authority was that it would fight terrorism,” the official added. “That is no longer clear.”
There has been an outpouring of support for the kidnapped students in Israel and around the world. A Twitter campaign with the hashtag #BringBackOurBoys has been launched. Saturday night saw a gathering at the Kotel (Western Wall) in Jerusalem.
(The Hebrew is translated “Our brothers, the house of Israel, who are immersed in trouble and captivity, standing between the sea and the dry land – may the Omnipresent one have mercy upon them and take them out from distress to relief, from darkness to light, and from captivity to freedom, now, speedily and soon.”)
Another gathering is planned for this evening. Jewish communities all over the world are holding vigils and prayers for the three.
In the United States many synagogues recited Psalms for the safe return of the boys.
Paula R. Stern made a very apt observation in her Times of Israel blog.
But isn’t it interesting that we deal with our anger by holding a mass prayer rally? Isn’t it amazing that we don’t hand out sweets in the street when our enemies suffer?
Which brings us to how the other side has reacted.
Petra Marquardt-Bigman documented the vicious approach of Ali Abunimah and his website Electronic Intifada.
Supposedly, the content offered by EI reflects “the commitment of its cofounders and editors to universal principles of human rights, international law, anti-racism and equal justice.” However, the EI does not hide that when it comes to Israel and its Jewish citizens as well as supporters of the Jewish state, these laudable principles are replaced by a truly Orwellian definition of antisemitism that reflects Abunimah’s preposterous view that “Zionism is one of the worst forms of anti-Semitism in existence today” and that support for Zionism “is not atonement for the Holocaust, but its continuation in spirit.”
Given these views, it is hardly surprising that Abunimah sometimes finds it difficult to conceal his enthusiasm for the kind of murderous “resistance” practiced by terrorist groups like Hamas and Islamic Jihad. It is equally unsurprising that Abunimah would now refer to the three recently kidnapped Jewish teenagers as “settlers” and to the security forces searching for them as “occupation gangs” – which, in the context of Abunimah’s ideology, implies that the three yeshiva students were legitimate targets of the “resistance” that Abunimah supports.
Aussie Dave of Israelly Cool has a collection of photographs of Palestinian celebrations of the kidnappings, reminiscent of those following 9/11.
For example of the celebrations there’s this from Khaled Abu Toameh.
And yes you read correctly, that says “Fatah students.”
On one side of the conflict there is pain and hope. On the other there is celebration, mocking and hatred.
When the Palestinian unity government was announced two weeks ago, State Department spokeswoman Jen Psaki said:
Well, at this point, it appears that President Abbas has formed an interim technocratic government that does not include ministers affiliated with Hamas. Moving forward, we will be judging this government by its actions. Based on what we know now, we intend to work with this government, but we’ll be watching closely to ensure that it upholds the principles that President Abbas reiterated today.
Has the United States seen enough yet?
[Photo: TwitterPic from IDF ]