French diplomat stars in latest Pallywood production
The EU is all up on arms because a French diplomat supposedly was roughed up by Israeli soldiers.
The background is that the Israeli Supreme Court — which often sides against the Israeli military — upheld the demolition of a Palestinian encampment built in the Jordan Valley in the West Bank without a permit.
A group of Palestinian activists assisted by European activists, including some diplomats, then sent trucks with supplies to reestablish the encampment.
The posse was accompanied by the usual phalanx of photographers and videographers, some wearing UN vests, because the purpose was to provoke a confrontation which would be a YouTube hit.
And so it was. The YouTube moment was when French diplomat Marion Castaing fell to the ground and the photo was broadcast around the world as her being assaulted by Israeli troops.
“They dragged me out of the truck and forced me to the ground with no regard for my diplomatic immunity,” French diplomat Marion Castaing said.
“This is how international law is being respected here,” she said, covered with dust.
The IDF stated that “reports that foreign diplomats abused their diplomatic privileges are currently being reviewed, and if required, complaints will be filed with the relevant authorities.”
But is that really what happened? Was she really “dragged” from the vehicle and “forced” to the ground?
In an Iranian Press TV report (at 0.35), Castaing is seen on the driver’s side with soldiers talking with her calmly.
A fairly complete raw video is posted here. You can see the mayhem created by the protesters.
I have excerpted the relevant part. The excerpt starts with a view from the driver, and there is no evidence Castaing is being hit or physically assaulted.
The camera then moves around the rear to the passenger side, and you see Castaing being removed from the vehicle.
There is no evidence of the Israeli soldiers hitting her or beating her or otherwise forcing her to the ground.
Instead, Castaing appears to fall to the ground on her own as the Israeli soldier try to hold her up.
Here is a screen capture as the soldiers try to prevent her from falling the ground. They are not pushing her to the ground, but trying to hold her up.
Here’s the video:
This Reuters photo (via Ynet) misleadingly is captioned “French diplomat dragged out of truck,” while the video makes clear it is soldiers trying to keep her from dropping to the ground after she already was outside the vehicle:
Castaing then stayed on the ground for a few seconds, during which photographers rushed to take her photo.
In another video posted online, you can see that Castaing started off on the driver’s side, men left the passenger side without being pulled out — the video then cuts away and Castaing is not seen again until she is on the ground. At the 2:50 mark, a soldier tries to lift her off the ground, but she pulls her arm back and stays on the ground.
Castaing then got up and punched one of the soldiers in the face, as seen in this excerpt from the Iranian TV report:
Among the many inflated claims, Israeli soldiers also are accused of pointing a gun at Castaing. On the IDF’s official blog (h/t Israel Matzav), the IDF has the following to say (backed up by photo evidence):
The photo us (led to spread this misinformation was taken as a screenshot from a video with footage clearly showing that Marion Castaing was neither physically dragged to the floor nor had guns pointed at her. Also, the photo clearly shows that the officer is holding his gun by the magazine, nowhere near the rifle’s grip.
Video is not always conclusive. A lot depends on camera angle.
Multiple video angles and raw video contradict the French diplomat’s claims that she was roughed up by Israeli soldiers.
There is a larger question, of course. Why are European diplomats acting as provocateurs rather than diplomats? Do Israeli diplomats in Paris participate in demonstrations against the French government?
How would France react if an Israeli diplomat led protesters attempting to circumvent a French judiciary ruling and then punched a French policeman in the face?
Update 9-22-2013: Via Haaretz, this description of Castaing’s conduct by the Israeli Foreign Ministry is consistent with our video analysis:
The Foreign Ministry said that videos of the incident show the Border Policemen and Israel Defense Forces soldiers at the scene did not exert any force against Castaing….
The Foreign Ministry also said that Castaing refused a police request to get out of the Palestinian truck in which she was sitting, and when she eventually did get out, she laid herself on the ground and refused to move.
Also, BBC Watch has the screenshot showing Castaing exiting the truck standing up — not being dragged out and pushed down.
I think we’ve seen enough from the multiple videos from several angles to declare that this was staged by Castaing for dramatic effect. She exited the truck standing up, deliberately dropped down to the ground as the Israeli soldiers tried to hold her upright, she then stayed on the ground long enough for a photo op, then got up and punched an Israeli soldier in the face.