Swarthmore College Faculty Members ‘Deeply Concerned’ About Academic Freedom of Pro-Palestinian Activists on Campus
“We are alarmed by the use of such tactics at a time when academic institutions should reaffirm their commitment to free speech.”
Isn’t it fascinating how many people are suddenly worried about free speech rights on campus? Where have these people been?
NEW: Statement on “academic freedom” by 41 @swarthmore faculty quickly goes off the rails:
The idea that “the classroom is not a political space or that the College is a neutral institution” is a “fantasy” that “obscures the College’s ongoing complicity with U.S. militarism.” pic.twitter.com/XitgPPKmN7
— Steve McGuire (@sfmcguire79) December 18, 2023
From the Phoenix:
Swarthmore Faculty on Academic Freedom and the Gaza Crisis
As faculty members at Swarthmore College, we are deeply concerned about the erosion of academic freedom in the United States, particularly in regards to the ongoing crisis in Gaza. Over the past few weeks, we have learned that our administration has made several attempts to discourage, intimidate, and/or silence pro-Palestine speech on campus. According to reports by students and faculty, college officials have warned specific students about their activism via personally-directed emails; they have selectively enforced rules concerning flyering, postering, and/or demonstrating on campus; they have privately requested that specific instructors refrain from moving their classes to the site of an ongoing sit-in, even if they do so at the request and/or with the unanimous consent of their students; and they have reassured alumni that the college will pursue “counter-programming” in response to support for Palestine. These deterrence measures have the effect of frightening faculty and students alike from engaging in legitimate and non-violent freedom of expression, and they have set a worrying precedent for future events and conflicts.
We are alarmed by the use of such tactics at a time when academic institutions should reaffirm their commitment to free speech. Speaking to the renewed debates about academic freedom since Oct. 7, Princeton professor Keith Whittington has recently suggested that colleges may either “reaffirm their core principles on free speech and academic freedom,” or “bow to political pressure and double down on an ethos of safetyism and a machinery of speech surveillance and suppression.” In its latest statement, the American Association of University Professors has similarly insisted that college officials “resist demands from politicians, trustees, donors, students and their parents, alumni, or other parties to punish faculty members for exercising [their academic] freedom.” We therefore urge our administration to refrain from joining a nationwide campaign, reminiscent of McCarthyism, against colleges and universities that aims to crack down on thought, speech, and actions that are critical of Israel.
All members of our campus community must be able to freely express themselves during such a pivotal moment in history. The suggestion that the classroom is not a political space or that the College is a neutral institution that is in some way hermetically sealed from our broader geopolitical context contradicts the College’s commitment to rigorous scholarship that engages with the most pressing contemporary issues. This fantasy also obscures the College’s ongoing complicity with U.S. militarism. Public protests and sit-ins can be generative spaces for deliberating about issues of justice, ethics, and policy, and for reminding us that our pedagogy is inextricably embedded in a wider material reality. In the present context, they are particularly important for giving students room to voice their sincere concerns regarding the Israeli military assault on Gaza and their desire for better understanding this world-historical event.
DONATE
Donations tax deductible
to the full extent allowed by law.
Comments
According to THE MOST INTERESTING MAN:
“I don’t encourage everyone to go to college,
but for those who do go,
I recommend that they go abroad.”
——-
Hey you parents out there:
Do you really believe tuition room and board at Swarthmore will ever pay for itself? These people have nothing to offer your child.
Do you really want your child anywhere near Philadelphia for four years?
Students don’t have ownership rights to campus facilities and property. They have no right to disturb other the other students quiet enjoyment of the premises. The analogy is if you are hotel guest, you can’t run riot in the hotel halls or lobby and disturb other guests. The other guests have the right to quiet enjoyment of the premises. The college is within its right to rusticate the shit disturbers from campus, and require them to take internet only courses, which is real feasibility post pandemic. If they return to campus, the college would be within its right to trespass them, and expel them. Swarthmore has low acceptance rate, and those students could be easily replaced.
Does LI shadow ban comments?
They “hold for moderation.” On a page where you see your own comment, examine the URL at top. If it’s in moderation purgatory, the additional options in the string will be obvious.
Students don’t have ownership rights to campus facilities and property. They have no right to disturb other students quiet enjoyment of the premises. The analogy is if you are hotel guest, you can’t run riot in the hotel halls or lobby and disturb other guests. The other guests have the right to quiet enjoyment of the premises. The college is within its right to rusticate them from campus, and require them to take internet only courses, which is real feasibility post pandemic. If they return to campus, the college would be within its right to trespass them, and expel them. Swarthmore has low acceptance rate, and those students could be easily replaced.
“wider material reality”
Who talks like that?
Put down the bong son, class is starting.
Where’s the deep concern for conservative voices, whites, pro-lifers, Trump supporters…. Oh wait yah… free speech is only for the extreme leftists on todays college campus
Yes, let’s make sure the fascists can fascist unimpeded.
Have some students put up some pro-Trump signs. See how much the Profs like “academic freedom” applied to them.