Judge David McNamee cleared a biological man who identifies as a woman for indecent exposure because he is too fat to have his genitals exposed.
The ruling only hit major outlets on Sunday. It quietly went through Ohio a week ago:
In a decision filed Friday evening, McNamee said there was “little dispute as to the facts of the case.” He noted that the Executive Director of the Fairborn YMCA, Jacqueline Brockman, testified that Glines was authorized by herself and other employees to use the women’s locker room at all Greater Dayton area YMCA facilities, including the Xenia location.
“There is no question that [Glines] was in the women’s locker room. However, [Glines] was not charged with trespass, nor was [Glines] charged with being in an area of the YMCA where [Glines] was not supposed to be. Quiet [sic] simply, the facts do not exist to support a find of guilt, as charges,” McNamee wrote.
In a statement release Monday, Glines’ attorneys said the facts and law were on Glines’ side “from the beginning.”
“It’s unfortunate not only for her, but for the entire community, that the filing of these charges ever occurred. We are grateful that the rule of law and the truth prevailed so that Ms. Glines and the community can move on in peace,” Lauren Dever and Keara Dever, attorneys for Glines, said in a statement.
There have been three complaints against Glines since 2021. In one complaint, a woman said three juvenile females were there during the incident.
A woman said a worker told her that it was okay because the guy was actually a woman and she “shouldn’t have been disturbed.”
One YMCA employee said she got a restraining order against Glines after he assaulted her:
Kateisha Young told Reduxx that Glines grabbed her genitals after they had gone out to coffee.
Young claims that following the assault Glines started attending her place of work, knowing when she would be working.
She added that she is concerned that she will be forced to find other work once her protection order against Glines runs out in 2024.
DONATE
Donations tax deductible
to the full extent allowed by law.
Comments
Who knew? Sometimes trans fat can be protective.
Trans-privilege!
“Science!”
They’re certainly preservative.
Phat Defense!
“I don’t know what we can do to defend this. So, you were naked in the women’s locker room”?
“Yeah”
“You flashed your junk at them”?
“Yeah”
“huh….say, stand up and turn around for me”
“? ok”
“I got an idea and just hear me out…”
How dare they call a tranny “fat”?
Isn’t that degrading?
Underheight.
Transfat is now healthy!
trans/social… distanced from the transgender spectrum in symbols and rhetoric. A female in this Rainbow spectrum opened a mass abortion field… soon forgotten (SS BLM). #Some, Select Black Lives Matter
“A judge ruled that a transgender woman could not have indecently exposed her penis….”
The Grammar Check function on their computer probably smoked the hard drive trying to decipher that one.
Judge need to lose its job
ya know- the YMCA has had a lot of problems with locker room theft.
Just saying.
But he could see theirs judge. Maybe conversion surgery if caught doing it again would solve the issue.
When institutions hijacked by lefty wokiesta weirdos refuse common sense and impose policies that harm stop giving them your support. Don’t send them money, don’t support their organization. Instead ID their allies and donors and boycott their ass as well. Local Church holds a bake sale at the YMCA? Depart the congregation. Same Church offers services to an orphanage? Tough cookies, boycott the orphanage. The orphanage needs a zoning variance? Show up to speak in opposition, organize to fund legal action to prevent it.
That’s the only way to make clear to intolerant lefty wokiesta bullies that we will be just as politically ruthless and just as prepared to go all in to maintain our cultural norms as they are in seeking to undermine them. Sucks b/c there will be collateral damage, like the orphans in this example. Casualties occur in war and a cultural war is no different in this respect.
We can’t allow them to use our decency to restrain us from vigorous and ruthless opposition. We tried that and got our ass whipped repeatedly as the leftists long march through our institutions clearly shows.
Was this argument merely accepted at face value, or did the judge require documentary evidence of this degree of obesity?
So are you asking whether the evidence would have stood up in court?
Wouldn’t that have been “fat shaming”?
Trans AND fat? So brave
So this judge is an honest-to-goodness judge? Went to law school and everything? Well…I guess a law degree isn’t what it’s cracked up to be.
And you thought “Draw Lucky” was just so you could get into art school.
Would that argument against a charge of indecent exposure be accepted if the same thing happened if a fat man who did not suffer transdelusion did what this sickbusturd did? I have a feeling , nope.
I really hate to be crude but here goes. Is the judge aware that the penis sort of, kind of, has this mechanism where it is not always the same size? I know biology that reminds us of sex differences is out of favor these days but I am just so hidebound I had to ask. Even when at rest it is difficult not to know that a naked man’s penis is located between his legs and if there is nothing covering his bottom half YOU WILL PROBABLY SEE A PENIS. Fat stomach or no fat stomach. There is a reason naked men are nervous around cats.
All speculation aside we know there was at least one dick in the courtroom. The Judge.
The real villain here is not the Judge, but the executive director of the YMCA. — “Executive Director of the Fairborn YMCA, Jacqueline Brockman, testified that Glines was authorized by herself and other employees to use the women’s locker room at all Greater Dayton area YMCA facilities, including the Xenia.”
Well, we know from lots of other such reports that the Ys are proudly in the forefront of gender-bending policy. As a kid, I used to enjoy using their pool and trampoline (this was before trampolines came with seatbelts, airbags, and bubblewrap). Now I wouldn’t let my grandkid go in to use the water fountain.
No surprise there, as the YMCA has long been a haven for gay men to meet and do whatever it is they do.
I think there might even be a song about that…
Well, at base, the YMCA is a gendered gym, and I imagine it’s not special in that regard.
Combine that with the fact that a female YMCA employee had a restraining order of some sort against Glines (following his physically assaulting her) and that Glines apparently continued to stalk her at work, with the Executive Director’s explicit authorization for him to be there.
That sounds like lawsuit material.
the fix for that is a .32 revolver
There are penises everywhere in Italy. I don’t know how women cope.
It’s a lever to complain about something else. That’s easily fixed by having a penis locker room and a vagina locker room, rather than men’s and women’s.
Yep. Sort by equipment and stop the stupid.
If you have a dick, you don’t belong in a women’s locker room. The only exception is boys under the age of five.
This isn’t rocket science.
I’m positive there is an old joke about a flasher or a rapist who was hauled into court, ended up having to show his tackle to the judge, and got acquitted on “insufficient evidence.”
Comedians say that comedy is often just tragedy plus time.
Democrat policy is almost always just comedy plus time.
Don’t forget the senile, old attempted rapist who was charged with assault with a dead weapon.
There was an old joke that rape charges against the silent movie actor Fatty Arbuckle were dismissed on the grounds of physical impossibility.
Women need to arm themselves and give these obnoxious, misogynstic and threatening male tranny narcissist-pervs the lead sandwiches they so richly deserve.
I guess this guy has what the Germans call “Spiegel Eier” (Mirror Eggs). That means you are so fat that you need a mirror to see your “eggs” (and other “accoutrements”). HA!
Der Grosser.
a good dose of pepper spray in the groin
will do wonders … had a female correctional office do that to a convict who
showed her his junk.
you could hear his screams all over the compound ….
That would spice things up, but would lead to assault of a friendly weapon.
Good illustration of what happens when a self-righteous judge decides to be “cute”. This is an invitation to this pervert to walk around, anywhere, completely naked.
From
https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-12054769/Trans-woman-cleared-flashing-penis-YMCA-shes-FAT-genitals-visible.html
To what extent did this judge take evidence on this issue?
In any event, defendant Darren Glines, who would otherwise not see an unclothed female live and in person, has worked out quite a scheme.
That may actually be worse:
Sexual Harassment and You
The thing that prevents a fat man’s penis from showing is called a panis. That is the large fold of skin that hangs down and covers his willie. In the future, he can strip off his clothes and expose his panis with no fear of being arrested for showing his penis. Just one vowel can make things legal.
Pannus adiposus.
https://medical-dictionary.thefreedictionary.com/panniculus+adiposus
.
Can we stop giving the wacko left a victory? Don’t call them “transwomen”. Call them “men posing as women”.
Use quotation marks. Call them trans”women.” Say “men” posing as women. Pronouns should be “her” or “hers.” It’ll relieve confusion.
.
I’m so old I remember what YMCA is an acronym for.
The judge is too woke to competently serve as a jurist. However, the YMCA created the problem by allowing men to use the female locker rooms. Sounds like the Woke-Y isn’t safe for children or women. Why do people stand for this?
A point many commenters seem to miss is that the judge had to rule in accordance with Ohio law as it’s written, not as he wishes it was written. If he hadn’t done that, at least two things would have happened: He would have been vocally called out by the leftie loons and would likely have been reversed on appeal.
None of like this but it is what it is.
.
Gotta say that he has one great lawyer to through that defense against the wall and make it stick
It’s YMCA why are women there at all?
Money.