Most Read
Image 01 Image 02 Image 03

Some Colleges Now Encouraging Student Groups to Investigate and Judge COVID Rule Violations

Some Colleges Now Encouraging Student Groups to Investigate and Judge COVID Rule Violations

“a student-led judiciary that looks into reports of students neglecting to wear masks or socially distance”

Institutionalized snitching. This is just another step towards Mao’s Cultural Revolution.

Inside Higher Ed reports:

Peer-Led Punishment for Flouting Pandemic Rules

Mel Xiao, a Rice University senior who helps investigate and adjudicate COVID-19 rule violations by other students, doesn’t mind if she’s viewed by her peers as “big brother” on campus.

Xiao is one of 11 students at Rice who served as a judge on the COVID Community Court, or CCC, a student-led judiciary that looks into reports of students neglecting to wear masks or socially distance, or who are hosting visitors in their dorm rooms, which are violations of the university’s Culture of Care Agreement for the 2020-21 academic year. A three-judge panel hears and investigates each low-level COVID-19-related violation and doles out “educational” punishments, such as writing an apology letter or hanging up posters that promote public health measures in their dorm, said Emily Garza, director of student judicial programs at Rice.

While Xiao and Garza believe the student-on-student disciplinary process is more effective than sending minor violations directly to university officials, Xiao has heard some criticism by students on social media. Students say they don’t want to be a “snitch” and report violations by friends, or argue that the CCC isn’t a “big deal” since it only handles violations that occur on campus, she said.

There are students who view the CCC as an extra set of eyes, waiting for them to slip up so they can be reprimanded. And some Rice alumni have weighed in on social media to consider the idea of a student court and question the need for it, while others have made fun of the notion of students policing each other and turning each other in. Xiao said she’s been thinking about these negative perceptions of the student court as she considers applying to be a judge again in the spring.

DONATE

Donations tax deductible
to the full extent allowed by law.

Comments

Red Guard. Mel Xiao. They’re not even hiding it anymore.

Kinda makes you want to see how these snitches and the commissars they report to would react to being ostracized and ‘canceled’ doesn’t it? (“Be careful around Jane Doe, she’s a snitch that turns people in to Commissar Xiao and the others who set themselves out to be our superiors so the ‘offenders’ can make sure they get their minds right.”).

    The Friendly Grizzly in reply to Idonttweet. | December 13, 2020 at 11:15 am

    I would like to see how these snitches and the commisars would respond to a blanket party, or, an outright curb-stomping.

This is just another step towards Mao’s Cultural Revolution

An especially appropriate comment considering the named judge is Mel Xiao.

Font Resize
Contrast Mode
Send this to a friend