Most Read
Image 01 Image 02 Image 03

Out of Control: Online Mob Wrongly Targets Florida Reporter

Out of Control: Online Mob Wrongly Targets Florida Reporter

“Please share this story if you can. Kindness matters. Truth matters. I hope, in this case, the truth can drown out the lies.”

Haley Hinds, a reporter for Tampa’s Fox affiliate station, was wrongly targeted by an online mob last week. A video showing a woman ranting nastiness at a nail salon owner went viral. Hinds was contacted via Facebook messenger asking if she was the woman in the video.

“Hello, were you the one in the nail salon video? If not, ignore this completely. If so, I thought you should read this tweet. Compassion is key – you are not above anyone,” the message read.

Hinds responded, saying she was definitely not the person in the video, that whomever the nasty woman was, she was not in anyway connected to the station, and that she agreed compassion was paramount.

Moments later, her picture was attached to the video and she was accused of being the nasty woman on film.

Hinds explained the entire story on her public Facebook page.

Twitter was no help and refused to intervene:

Hinds received death threats, invitations to end her own life, and all manner of vile insult just because some internet rando assumed she was the woman in a video.

These last few weeks, hoards of angry people, usually directed by someone harboring malintent, have harassed several innocent people. We’ve been covering the unfortunate change of tone extensively.

If they don’t stop, someone is going to get seriously hurt, or worse.

Full text of Hinds’ post here:

What would you do if a random stranger on the internet decided to falsely accuse you of being the “star” of a recently viral video of a woman going on a racist tirade at a Lutz, FL nail salon?

And what would you do if, afterward, an Internet mob came after you, from all over the world, threatening you, calling you vile names, even telling you to go kill yourself?

Well, folks… I’ll tell you all about it. Because it happened to me.

It’s a crummy situation that leaves me not only disappointed in the person who decided to target me for no reason, but also, really concerned about those who blindly went along with it.

It was Tuesday afternoon. I was sitting in the passenger seat of a parked SUV in Fort Meade. As I was working on my script for a 5:30 p.m. live shot, I received a Facebook message. A woman asked, “Hello, were you the one in the nail salon video? If not, ignore this completely. If so, I thought you should read this tweet. Compassion is key – you are not above anyone.”

I shook my head and thought, that’s really weird. I responded, “No, that is definitely not me. And, that woman has absolutely no connection to the place where I work. I agree with you, compassion is key and so needed in this world.”

I mentioned she had no connection to the station because, in the video, you’ll hear the woman claim she’s dating a “channel 13 news advisor” and threatening that “you’ll get put on the news.” She has no affiliation with the station and there’s no position called “news advisor.”

A few minutes later, my phone buzzes. It buzzes again. And again. And again. I soon learned that a Twitter user named @carneashannah posted a screenshot of my personal Facebook page underneath the viral video, saying, “couldn’t find a Twitter but I did find a Facebook.” She also posted a screenshot of my boyfriend’s Facebook page, which included a photo of his family.

Here’s how it all snowballed. Though that video had been tweeted by AJ+ to its nearly one million followers a few days before, civil rights activist and writer Shaun King had just retweeted it, asking his nearly one million followers, “What’s her name?”

The witch hunt began. And, for a reason that I still don’t quite understand, a woman from the other side of the country decided to pick me.

The hate messages began.

“You’re a racist piece of sh*t for what you did to the nail salon lady… you are a disgrace.”

“Kill yourself you stupid b*tch, you don’t deserve to be a part of America.”

And then, there were Twitter users who willingly went along with it.

“Show this ‘Fox news reporter’ who she really is..a racist pos.”

“Fox News reporter. Of course.”

Retweet. Retweet. Retweet.

Like. Like. Like.

Even after some Twitter users started to realize that the woman in the video looks/sounds nothing like me, and is clearly a few years older, the trolling continued.

“We’ve tried peace and love for a long time and it doesn’t seem to be working. Let’s see what retaliatory violence gets us,” one person posted.

“You can see a video of her berating a woman and you say she is the sweetest thing. White privilege, you don’t like to be told when you’re wrong,” another one replied.

Days later, the tweet with my photo still remains up for all the world to see, with the likes and retweets piling up. My co-workers, family and friends thought that, surely, by reporting the tweets, they would be removed for sparking this barrage of harassment, not to mention, the damage of my reputation. We thought.

Each of us received e-mails from Twitter saying, “there was no violation of the Twitter rules against abusive behavior.” The e-mail went on to say, “Some tweets may seem to be abusive when viewed in isolation, but may not be when viewed in the context of a larger conversation.” I’ve attached photos of their e-mail in which they explained further.

I’m left shaking my head, wondering what inspires someone thousands of miles away to want to turn someone’s life upside down, to attempt to destroy their reputation in such a large way, and to, potentially, put them in actual danger.

I’m left shaking my head, wondering how so many people on the Internet are willing to abandon their critical thinking skills, their eyesight, their hearing, and to blindly pull out their pitchforks because they’re so desperate to find a villain. They’ll believe whatever someone else says, whether it’s true or not. Truth just doesn’t seem to matter at the time.

It’s how intentionally inaccurate memes and pictures spread like wildfire. It’s how fake news pops up all over the internet. It’s sad and it’s scary and it’s a problem that’s only getting worse.

We live in a world where bullying, especially, cyberbullying is becoming commonplace. With the job I do, I’ve developed pretty thick skin. I’ve been called just about every name in the book for simply doing the job that I do. I’m sort of used to it.

But, not everyone is. This type of cyberbullying, in which one person seeks to destroy another, can have real consequences. It’s not just about defamation. It can lead people who are struggling with anxiety or depression to feel hopeless, abandoned, constantly targeted and can push them to possibly take their own lives in an attempt to make the abuse stop. All of this, because of some stupid, mindless, cruel joke.

Every time I see viral videos of people spewing hate, mistreating those who speak another language, I get angry. Trust me, I follow Shaun King. In fact, I kind of hoped he’d pick up the video from Lutz and help identify who that person was.

BUT.

This type of witch hunt becomes an extremely dangerous game when people go searching relentlessly for a villain, any villain, just to say they got them. It can ruin innocent people’s lives.

Now, I must point out that there were many good characters in this story. Eventually, several strangers from Twitter came to my defense, urging @carneashannah to delete the tweet, that it was inaccurate, that it was irresponsible and mean-spirited. Old friends and co-workers, some who I haven’t seen in years, jumped into the mess to set the record straight. Some of our wonderful viewers did, too. And, some, who had originally shared the malicious tweet, actually went back and removed it from their pages.

No matter what, there will ALWAYS be more good people in the world than bad. I’ll never stop believing that. I’m so thankful for all those who fought for the truth. Unfortunately, the damage has already been done.

I used some of my investigative skills to figure out exactly who posted the original tweet. I traced it back to a woman living in southern California. I’m not going to name her because two wrongs don’t make right. But, I’ve reached out to her in a number of ways.

Whether or not she deletes the tweet remains to be seen. I believe everyone makes mistakes and is worthy of redemption. I just hope she takes this opportunity to do the right thing.

In the meantime, I have a request for everyone: Think before you share a post. Think before you retweet. Fact. Check. Everything. Because what you’re sharing may be totally false and could make you, unknowingly, an accessory to a malicious effort to destroy another person’s life.

Please share this story if you can. Kindness matters. Truth matters. I hope, in this case, the truth can drown out the lies.

DONATE

Donations tax deductible
to the full extent allowed by law.

Tags:

Comments

ahad haamoratsim | June 25, 2018 at 3:21 pm

This seems to be the Twitter version of SWATTing someone.

    casualobserver in reply to ahad haamoratsim. | June 25, 2018 at 3:39 pm

    To me this epitomizes over half, if not the vast majority of routine social media account holder’s. More so Twitter perhaps. But people spend a lot of their time searching for opposing opinions or threads to join to express some recurring or eve new found outrage. It’s like their own opioid.

I’ve been saying it in the last day but I think it’s not just this case, I think it’s basically all cases in a long string of events. People have been working themselves up in online rages for so long, without results, that they are trying, through fits and starts, to force their combined will into the real world and to have an impact… which has the same meaning as in their world: to ruin someone’s life and exile the person from civilization, or in extremes, life itself.

In far too many senses than I would like, we need to “get real”.

inspectorudy | June 25, 2018 at 3:34 pm

The answer is to get off of all this garbage. Facebook, twitter, and all of the other gossip networks. When you lie down with dogs don’t complain about the fleas!

    You seem to be implying that just because Haley Hinds has a Facebook account (which is normal for anyone with her job) or a Twitter account (ditto) she should expect to be harassed over the actions of a complete stranger.

    That’s crazy. I down voted you because blaming a randomly chosen victim for being in the pool of random choices is ridiculous.

      inspectorudy in reply to irv. | June 26, 2018 at 12:38 am

      I know most of you on this site are members of the social maelstrom and you will have to live and die by your choice. Being on it is like having a normal life until your home is broken into or a child dies. Then you realize what is important in your lives. Most of you cannot go a day without clutching your phone. That’s your problem that is playing into the Google and Facebook owner’s hands. They will control all of your personal info and like this poor victim, you will have no power to do anything about it. Someday you will look back at your naivety in this matter and be astonished at how gullible you have been.

        Valerie in reply to inspectorudy. | June 26, 2018 at 4:38 am

        Gee, i wonder if Inspectorudy is being spoofed. So much prejudice in one ,bitter post. What a shame.

        healthguyfsu in reply to inspectorudy. | June 26, 2018 at 7:48 am

        While I wont’ be nearly so judgmental, I made the decision to leave facebook last year. It was tough at first because I was heavily ingrained with checking my feed as part of my daily routine.

        However, once I got used to it (by blocking the site on my browsers, so if I habitually typed it in I wouldn’t be able to access it), I feel like I came out more productive and less polarized to anger.

        I have a near defunct twitter account that I only use for ease of signing in to some linked accounts. I’ve never been a tweeter. I do have linked in for professional reasons, but that’s it.

          MajorWood in reply to healthguyfsu. | June 26, 2018 at 12:19 pm

          I left facebook years ago although my profile, as empty and false as it can get, appears to live on. I saw it for the huge time suck that it was. I do miss the “Dear Batt, your friends miss you” monthly emails for about a year. User name was Batt Guano, so it always gave me a chuckle.

          I find it interesting that “everyone can be tracked,” yet when you actually want to track someone, suddenly they don’t have that capability. One of those has to be an outright lie.

Big Nurse is watching.

It’s as if the Jacobians have teamed up with the Chinese and the Bolsheviks to bring us the next revolution.

I am off Twitter and have periodically gotten off FB but I am now certainly getting off it for good.

It’s not safe

At least one of the tweets about this called for “retaliatory violence” apparently against racists. I hope this innocent bystander doesn’t have to face that but she might want to consider arming herself, just in case the mob doesn’t stop at tweeting.

Facebook accounts need to come with a miranda type warning. Anything you post can and will be used against you and will be repeatedly sold to evil people for a few cents.

Sue already, for ten times what this chick will ever be worth. Leftist totalitarians need to be stopped with all available legal force.

There must have been a correlation between her and the women in the video. #Diversity

That said, #HateLovesAbortion.

    JohnSmith100 in reply to n.n. | June 25, 2018 at 4:52 pm

    Don’t you think that people launching these attacks are perfect candidates for retroactive abortions?

      It would still be progressive (i.e. monotonic), which is a superset concept that includes retroactive. It all depends on qualification of progress and the characeristics of the monotonic function. Also, we perceive and are capable of causal function in one direction in the “time” spectrum, but evolution (i.e. chaos) is not directional, it is omnidirectional. We just happen to exist in a plane with unusually stable attributes.

      Just some observations to test the narrow limits of the scientific logical domain. What do you think? In any case, the nature of space, or space and time, are not discernible by people or the scientific philosophy in its limited frame of reference.

      Yeah… No, I would not support a progressive abortion unless it was in self-defense. No proactive, premeditated, or elective abortions for lesser causes.

      #PrinciplesMatter Americans are not, in principle, Pro-Choice, selective, opportunistic, and politically congruent. We need a philosophy (i.e. guidance) that is internally, externally, and mutually consistent in order mitigate progressive corruption.

As ye sow…

I was sympathetic for the women, until she said she follows King and was hoping his followers would find the person.

“Every time I see viral videos of people spewing hate, mistreating those who speak another language, I get angry. Trust me, I follow Shaun King. In fact, I kind of hoped he’d pick up the video from Lutz and help identify who that person was.”

So witch hunt bad when they get the wrong person, but when seeing the video hopes King will retweet it and find the person. Hoping the witch hunt starts?

Given the privacy, abuse, and bias of the big social networks (FB, Twitter, LinkedIn etc.), it is probably time for any decent person with a life to abandon there venues for bullying and abuse.

I’m out.

Is it actionable to falsely accuse someone in this fashion?

Guy Gadbouis | June 25, 2018 at 8:41 pm

And people wonder why I don’t use social media…..

nordic_prince | June 25, 2018 at 11:44 pm

Well, Twitter said it didn’t violate their TOS, so it must be okay, ya know? Calm down, it’s only a witch hunt by a frenzied mob.

/sarc

After you find the person doing this ,, sue them for everything they have. Make an example out of them for other Looney Tunes in CA !!

harleycowboy | June 26, 2018 at 1:52 pm

“Well she looks like you.”
That’s close enough them to go all out ape shit.

Haley Hinds is a weekend anchor on our local Fox owned station in Tampa and is a fine young woman. She volunteers in the community, her station is known for their “care force” with charities like Metropolitan Ministries which do fabulous work for the homeless in our community. It is sad to watch this happen to her.

Font Resize
Contrast Mode
Send this to a friend