President Donald Trump’s pledge to deport millions of illegal aliens living in the U.S. was a central pillar of his 2024 campaign. Supporters argued that providing essential services to non-citizens placed a significant strain on state and municipal budgets, contributing to rising crime rates and diverting resources away from the education of American students. It was time to put America first.
Why then would at least 20 GOP lawmakers back a bill that grants conditional amnesty to those who have broken U.S. law?
The DIGNIDAD (Dignity) Act of 2025 (H.R. 4393) is being touted by the National Immigration Forum as a bipartisan immigration reform bill “aiming to secure the border, reform the asylum system, and provide a 7-year legal status program for undocumented immigrants.”
Supporters insist the legislation does not constitute amnesty or confer citizenship. Rather, it offers work authorization and a path to legal residency for millions of illegals who have been living here illegally the longest.
Upon introducing the measure in November, Florida Republican Rep. Maria Elvira Salazar, a co-sponsor of the bill, claimed, “The Dignity Act brings an urgently needed solution to the United States’ broken immigration system. It secures our borders, restores law and order, and provides a responsible, earned process for millions of hard-working people who have lived here for years and contributed to our country. The Dignity Act lowers costs for Americans, strengthens our workforce, and gives hard-working men and women a path forward. It is not citizenship. It is not amnesty. It is dignity.”
As supporters move to advance the DIGNIDAD Act in the House, Rep. Brandon Gill (R-TX) offered this blunt assessment on X: “The Dignity Act is mass amnesty and would constitute a terrible betrayal of our voters.”
Salazar immediately pounced on Gill, demanding that he “READ. THE. BILL. BEFORE. YOU. OPEN. YOUR. MOUTH.” She went on to say Gill’s remark was “a deliberate distortion and it exposes just how little you know about the bill.”
She argued:
This is enforcement first: zero tolerance for criminals, permanent border security, and hard, earned requirements to step forward and face the law, so American workers are protected, not undercut. Amnesty is the chaos you’ve defended, millions in the shadows, no control, no accountability, and a system that stopped working a long time ago. No shortcuts. No giveaways. No blanket forgiveness. That’s law and order. That’s DIGNITY.
It’s also amnesty!
Readers were quick to “add context” to Salazar’s attempt to deny the obvious truth about the bill’s objective. They wrote: “It grants amnesty: permanent residency (Dream Act), deferred action & legal status (Dignity Program), and halts deportations. Wipes 3/10 year bans, creates an inspected and admitted loophole, grants AG power to terminate deportation for family ‘hardship.'”
Several readers called Salazar’s bluff and read the entire 261-page bill. Among them was conservative political analyst — and former nuclear scientist — Matt Van Swol. Citing specific passages in the text, he concluded that it does indeed “support mass amnesty.” He posted the results of his analysis in the X post below.
Among Van Swol’s findings:
The Dream Act:[The bill grants] “conditional lawful permanent resident status to ILLEGAL ALIENS who:
- Have been continuously present in the U.S. since January 1, 2021
- Entered before age 18
- Meet education, employment, or military service requirements
- Pass criminal background checks
…DACA recipients get fast-tracked to conditional green card status … which is literally mass amnesty….BUT THE BILL GOES EVEN FURTHER!!!On pages 204-217, you present the Dignity Program:This is a separate track for illegal aliens who don’t qualify for the Dream Act.If you are an illegal aliens who:
- Was continuously present since December 31, 2020
- Pay a $1,000 upfront “restitution” fee
- Submit biometrics, pass a background check
- No felony convictions
You get work authorization + travel authorization + deferred removal for 7 yearsAfter completing the 7-year program (paying $7,000 total in fees, staying employed, obeying laws, paying back taxes): We grant you:
- “Dignity Status” which is essentially a lawful nonimmigrant status, which is renewable any number of times
- Work and travel authorization
The most powerful part of Van Swol’s analysis was his conclusions:
But the most important bit that you’re hiding here is that it totally suspends deportation of anyone who qualifies for this. This would effective end ALL MASS DEPORTATIONS in the United States immediately.You are a liar, you are a fraud, everything you stand for is fake… did YOU read your own bill? Because I just did, and you are a damned LIAR!!!!!
PJ Media’s Stephen Kruiser addressed the DIGNIDAD Act in a Thursday morning post. He also called Salazar a liar. According to Kruiser:
[The bill] basically grants permanent resident status to any illegal alien who can manage to hang around for a while without getting deported. That’s right, sports fans, the longer they’re successful at breaking the law, the greater the reward.ICE and Border Patrol agents have been facing angry mobs and death threats for trying to do their jobs and Republicans are linking arms with the people who have been ginning up those mobs. It’s a slap in the face to the agents, President Trump, and the law-abiding citizens of the United States. In what way, shape, or form does a Republican congresswoman from Florida think that this represents her constituents?
He called on the 20 “idiot, squish” Republicans who support this legislation to “read the room.”
Your weakness is pathetic, and your complicity in this amnesty scheme is decidedly un-American. May you all be ushered back into the private sector as quickly as possible.
Hear, hear!
Ultimately, the DIGNIDAD Act appears to represent a sharp departure from the tough enforcement stance many voters were promised, effectively blurring the line between reform and amnesty. Despite its branding, the bill would grant legal protections and halt deportations for millions, raising serious questions about whether mass deportation was ever a realistic or genuine objective.
This isn’t a compromise — it’s a capitulation that risks rewarding unlawful entry while undermining both immigration law and the trust of those who expected stricter enforcement.
[Below is a list of the 18 House Republicans who back the bill.]
Elizabeth writes commentary for Legal Insurrection and The Washington Examiner. She is an academy fellow at The Heritage Foundation. Please follow Elizabeth on X or LinkedIn.
CLICK HERE FOR FULL VERSION OF THIS STORY