South African President Cyril Ramaphosa faced a serious dilemma when a charter flight carrying 153 mostly undocumented Palestinians touched down at O.R. Tambo International Airport in Johannesburg on Thursday.
Haaretz reported, “This is the second group of Gazans to travel to South Africa in the past two weeks. The previous group took the same route and was admitted to Johannesburg without any issue.” No public statement was issued about the earlier group of 176 Palestinians said to have arrived on October 28.
For nearly two years since the October 7, 2023, massacre, Ramaphosa’s government has loudly proclaimed its solidarity with the Palestinian people. It has blasted Israel on the world stage — accusing it of “genocidal acts” in a December 2023 filing with the International Court of Justice, recalling diplomats, demanding sanctions, and urging global pressure against the Jewish state.
Many South African citizens and political groups have also declared their support for the Palestinians. According to The Guardian, “Civil society movements, inspired by South Africa’s anti-apartheid legacy, actively organize solidarity campaigns, boycotts, and aid efforts for Palestinians.”
But when 153 Palestinians actually arrived on South African soil, that professed solidarity suddenly evaporated. Officials kept the passengers trapped on a hot plane for more than 10 hours while the government scrambled to decide whether to allow them into the country. Only after a local charity agreed to provide humanitarian support did Ramaphosa approve entry for 130 of the passengers. The rest were sent on to other destinations.
Despite two years of fiery rhetoric about standing with Palestine, the mask has slipped, and it appears that South Africa’s show of unity has been more performance than principle. And Ramaphosa is facing fierce domestic backlash for letting them in.
Bracing for the outrage he knew was coming, Ramaphosa posted several clips on X from an earlier press conference in which he had defended his decision. He told reporters, “These are people from Gaza who somehow mysteriously were put on a plane that passed by Nairobi and came here.”
“Even though they do not have the necessary documents and papers, these are people from a strife-torn, a war-torn country.” They had been allowed into South Africa “out of compassion,” and “we cannot turn them back.”
He promised a full investigation into their “mysterious” arrival.
His post was greeted with disgust by many of his constituents. An open letter from a South African immigration analyst to Ramaphosa echoes the anger and frustration expressed by many citizens over the Palestinians’ arrival.
You are a traitor and a disgrace to our nation….By aligning yourself with individuals and groups notorious for their violent ideologies and destructive agendas, you have betrayed the principles of peace, justice, and sovereignty that our nation holds dear.This reckless behavior exposes our citizens to unnecessary risks, invites international condemnation, and weakens the very fabric of our society.History will judge you harshly for prioritizing personal or political gains over the welfare of the nation.Your leadership, once promised to unite and uplift, now sows division and invites peril.
The missive ended with a call for Ramaphosa’s resignation, followed by the searing sign-off, “With disgust and profound disappointment.”
At the start of the Israel–Hamas war, it seemed a no-brainer that Egypt or Jordan would accept Gazans seeking refuge. But both countries refused.
There was a valid reason for this: They were worried that Hamas, which is known for blending in with civilians, would gain a foothold in their countries. And aside from Qatar, no Arab nation wants Hamas, a branch of the Muslim Brotherhood, operating inside its borders. They rightly feared that the terrorist group’s presence would destabilize their countries and pose a serious threat to their national security.
At an October 2023 news conference in Cairo, Egyptian President Abdel Fattah el Sisi told reporters, “What is happening now in Gaza is an attempt to force civilian residents to take refuge and migrate to Egypt, which should not be accepted.
“Egypt rejects any attempt to resolve the Palestinian issue by military means or through the forced displacement of Palestinians from their land, which would come at the expense of the countries of the region,” he said.
Sisi was concerned that the flow of Palestinians into Sinai would include militants who would use it as a staging ground for attacks against Israel. The ensuing military action could easily upset the 1979 Egypt-Israel peace treaty.
Egyptian Prime Minister Mostafa Madbouly went even further. He declared, “We are ready to sacrifice millions of lives to protect our territory from any encroachment.”
Jordan’s King Abdullah II agreed: “No refugees in Jordan, no refugees in Egypt.”
Abdullah well remembers his father’s expulsion of thousands of Palestinians from Jordan following a September 1970 coup attempt by the Palestine Liberation Organization, an event better known as Black September.
A reader’s comment on an article that appeared on The Gatestone Institute’s site shortly after October 7, 2023, was especially helpful in understanding why no one wants the Palestinians in their countries.
Having spent many years working in the Middle East, the reader explained:
[The belief that] Arabs are a homogenous group is wrong in so many ways. But one thing they are almost unanimous on is that the Palestinians are at the bottom of the pecking order. Palestinians are seen as troublemakers, which in the volatile world of Arab politics, is undesirable. The fact they have laid themselves down at Hamas’s feet … makes them difficult to be supported by the Sunni States.Most Arabs wish that the Palestinians and Hamas would just go away. If Israel were to annex both Gaza and the West Bank and integrate these areas into Israel, the Arab countries would breathe a collective sigh of relief while at the same time [making] all the ‘right’ noises for the world’s stage. One thing the Arab governments will want is that Israel has the resolve to annihilate Hamas because it saves them a job they would dearly like to do themselves.
It’s easy for individuals, political groups, and governments to talk about “solidarity” with the Palestinian people. But when faced with the reality of Palestinians actually arriving in their countries, all that solidarity flies out the window.
Elizabeth writes commentary for Legal Insurrection and The Washington Examiner. She is an academy fellow at The Heritage Foundation. Please follow Elizabeth on X or LinkedIn.
CLICK HERE FOR FULL VERSION OF THIS STORY