For those of you unfamiliar with online shopping, Shein is a global fast fashion retailer originally founded in Nanjing, China, in 200. While Shein’s headquarters are now in Singapore, its main supply chain and manufacturing operations remain in China, particularly in the Guangzhou region, which is home to thousands of factories producing its products
Shein specializes in inexpensive, trendy clothing and accessories. It primarily targets young women but also offers men’s, children’s, and home goods. The company operates exclusively online through its website and app, serving customers in over 150 countries worldwide.
During the 2020 pandemic and the Biden Era, times were very good for the company. However, under President Donald Trump’s tariff system, times are now much harder.
Dozens of garment factories in the Guangzhou district (known as “Shein Village”) have closed or gone idle.
Until recently, these goods frequently made their way directly to American consumers who bought them at a fraction of the cost of clothes that are sold by US-based retailers thanks to a tax exemption for international shipments valued at $800 or less.“Orders from Shein have fallen this year, and our sales are down by a lot,” a worker at one workshop employing around 20 people told the Japanese news agency Nikkei.Trump’s removal of the de minimis policy, which goes into effect on May 2, means all shipments regardless of size now face import taxes.The policy had enabled online retailers such as Shein and Temu to keep prices competitive in the American market, crucially underpinning their business model.
While Shein may consider diversifying its supply chain and moving factories to Vietnam, the changes will seriously impact the business model.
A move to source more from Vietnam could help Shein to continue sending goods to the U.S. at lower tariff rates or without import duties at all for packages sent under de minimis – though there is no guarantee the threshold will remain in place for goods sent from Vietnam.But it also creates a Catch-22 situation for the company – a potentially costly and time-consuming one in an industry in which price and time are essential.”The diversification of its sourcing base and a significant change in its business model will have to go hand-in-hand for Shein,” said Sheng Lu, professor of fashion and apparel studies at the University of Delaware.Without fundamentally changing the business model of pumping out thousands of new styles in small batches and shipping them quickly to end consumers, Shein can’t diversify its supply chain, and without diversifying the supply chain away from South China, it can no longer ship products direct to U.S. consumers at low, tariff-free prices, Lu says.
Sadly for Shein, other countries seem to be making trade moves in their own interest. The United Kingdom Chancellor announced plans to beef up British protections against cheap imports.
Rachel Reeves said she would review rules on “low value imports” due to concerns they unfairly benefit foreign companies such as Temu and Shein at the expense of British high street stores.Under plans announced on Wednesday, the Trade Remedies Authority (TRA) will also “surge” resources into helping businesses report unfair practices such as “dumping”, in which goods are sold into the UK at below-market prices….Currently, imports valued under £135 do not have to pay customs duties, but some retailers have argued this gives preferential treatment to firms such as Temu and Shein that make and store products overseas and then ship them directly to UK customers.The Chancellor’s plan will see more resources given to the TRA’s pre-application office, which supports businesses with advice on what evidence it needs to launch investigations.
Joe Mannix, contributor at Ace of Spades HQ, notes that progressives should be happy about Trump’s tariffs and their ultimate impact on the environment.
It’s also an exemption that was the enemy of many an environmental group back when it was safe for progressives to attack it. The “Fast fashion” industry is hard on the environment (though that’s “over there” and environmental NIMBYism doesn’t care about “over there”) and borderline disastrous in terms of energy.The energy it takes to ship a Shein garment is significantly greater than it is for a garment delivered through bulk purchasing and distribution. The environmentalists have been talking about this for years now. Had Biden eliminated the de minimis exemption, they’d be cheering.Yet most are not. Orange Man is still Orange Man. The dichotomy is on display in many outlets.
But I am happy our supply chain is becoming less reliant on China.
CLICK HERE FOR FULL VERSION OF THIS STORY