The Vatican removed Jesus, the keffiyeh scarf, and the manger from a Nativity scene.
BEFORE I CONTINUE: A few reports say the Vatican removed the entire scene. Most outlets also report that they only removed Jesus, the scarf, and the manger.
It is tradition to present the entire scene to the pope. Then, they remove baby Jesus until December 24th.
I do not know if it is common for the Vatican only to remove Jesus or remove Jesus and the manger. I know my church has an empty manger.
Why am I saying all this? Because details matter, especially since the Vatican won’t say anything.
OK, so, when the Nativity scene came out, Jews and Catholics lashed out, especially since the scarf has long been a symbol of Palestinian revolts and hatred toward Israel.
The Catholic News Agency spoke with Johny Andonia, the man who led the project:
Speaking to CNA by phone from Cyprus, where he has an art residency until May, Andonia said he did not expect the scale of the reaction to the keffiyeh, which he also signed off on, after it was approved by people at the Vatican during the Nativity’s installation on Dec. 5.“It came about in a spontaneous way, actually, because we learned that the child baby Jesus has to be covered or even absent until the 24th of December, and [the on-the-ground coordinator] suggested to cover it with a keffiyeh,” the artist said on Dec. 13.“And they said no, no, not to cover him. And then he asked, can I put it then under [the child Jesus] and the people … in charge at that time accepted laying the keffiyeh under the baby Jesus, and this is how it came about.”
The Vatican approved of the scarf. I highly doubt the people there didn’t know of the scarf’s significance. Of course, Andonia played it down:
Andonia said he does not agree with commentary from some quarters that the keffiyeh indicates violence or the eradication of others. “It’s only about recognition,” he said. “This keffiyeh represents the people who had presented the Nativity scene.”
Well, in my initial post about the Nativity scene, I provided a history of the keffiyeh scarf. Yeah, it’s always been a symbol of revolts. Yasser Arafat popularized it in the 1960s.
CLICK HERE FOR FULL VERSION OF THIS STORY