Los Angeles ‘Mansion Tax’ has Become a Weapon of Fiscal Mass Destruction
The 2023 tax has effectively blocked the building of 9,100 homes, wiped out 16,650 full-time construction jobs and cost $452 million in revenue.
In the fall of 2023, voters in the city of Los Angeles approved a “mansion tax” that would impose a new transaction tax on any real estate sale over $5 million. The referendum was very popular, passing with nearly 58% of the vote and calling for the following:
- A 4% tax on properties sold or transferred for more than $5 million and a 5.5% tax on properties sold or transferred for more than $10 million;
- Establishing the House LA Fund within the city treasury to collect additional tax revenue; and
- Allocating revenue to projects that address housing availability at certain income thresholds and homelessness prevention.
Early signs suggested the “Mansion Tax” was an epic failure. LA elites swiftly sold their homes and left the area. The tax completely crushed the area’s high-end market.
The negative effects are continuing. A new report underscores what a spectacular failure the “Mansion Tax” has been, blocking new home construction, wiping out jobs, and failing to reap the money promised in the 2023 ad campaigns.
LA’s “mansion tax,” sold to Angelenos as a way to tax the rich and boost housing, has instead blocked the building of 9,100 homes, wiped out 16,650 full-time construction jobs and cost $452 million in revenue.
A damning new report says the tax, officially known as United to House LA, or ULA — has had a negative impact on the city’s high-end and multi-family real estate markets and collected less than half what it was expected to generate to tackle the city’s housing crisis.
The ULA was expected to raise about $900 million a year, or $2.7 billion over its first three years. Instead, it brought in about $1.2 billion.
…Despite its nickname, LA’s “mansion tax” applies far beyond luxury homes. Apartment buildings, offices, warehouses and vacant land can all trigger the tax if they sell above the thresholds.
About 1,000 of the 9,100-plus new homes lost would have been affordable units — the very thing the tax was supposed to create — according to RAND corporation, a non-partisan, nonprofit research group.
LA's 'mansion tax' backfires spectacularly as thousands of homes and jobs vanish https://t.co/1j1HG7SsCh pic.twitter.com/c7zEHngIGB
— New York Post (@nypost) October 4, 2026
I am sure Legal Insurrection readers will not be surprised to learn that the “Mansion Tax” was championed by socialist mayoral hopeful Councilwoman Nithya Raman.
The RAND Report, “The Effects of the Measure ULA (United to House LA) Transfer Tax on Economic Development and Municipal Finances in Los Angeles”, was released in May 2026 and is quite damning. While the tax has raised about $1.185 billion for affordable housing and tenant support since taking effect in 202, the tax has also reduced high-value property sales, slowed apartment construction, and lowered other tax and fee revenue for the city, schools, county, and state.
Another study’s findings are borne out by evidence that construction permits have plummeted since the 2023 tax was enacted.
…[A]ccording to a working paper from Yingru Pan, a Ph.D. student at UCLA Anderson School of Management, Measure ULA has had the unintended consequence of curbing construction of both budget-friendly and luxury housing across L.A., even as development in the suburbs has expanded.
In her 60-page analysis, titled “Taxing the Top, Building the Bottom? The Impact of Los Angeles’ Mansion Tax on Housing Supply and Affordability,” Pan argues that compared to 2018-2019 levels, before the passing of Measure ULA, overall construction permits in Los Angeles plummeted 40%.
A closer look at the housing data shows that multifamily construction permits fell 27%, while permits for single-family homes dropped 45%.
“Developers likely hesitated to pursue even moderately priced multi-family units due to perceived financial risks, such as cascading tax impacts on project valuations or uncertainty about future policy adjustments,” Pan writes.
According to the RAND report’s estimates, Measure ULA reduced high-value real estate transactions by about 31 percent and reduced permits for large apartment projects by about 30 percent. The authors estimate that these changes led to $452 million in lost public revenue through early 2026, including about $80 million for Los Angeles Unified School District, and that more than 16,000 full-time-equivalent construction jobs were not created. The report also finds that apartment buildings sold under the tax saw slightly faster rent growth afterward, suggesting some of the tax cost may be passed on to tenants through higher rents.
The RAND report authors offered some “fixes”, including a change to the tax so newer commercial and apartment properties are exempt for 15 years, while older commercial and apartment properties would face a lower tax rate. They also recommend keeping the current rate for high-value single-family home sales. They estimate these changes would increase revenue, housing construction, and jobs.
PSA: “Tax the rich” is not an economic plan.
LA’s “mansion tax” deterred an estimated 9,100 homes, cost 16,650 construction jobs and $452M in revenue.
Now Mamdani is selling NYC the same “tax the rich” philosophy.
How many times do we have to learn this lesson? pic.twitter.com/GDtC5cenmb
— Liz Benichou (@basedinmalibu) October 4, 2026
Interestingly, the report also recommends making ULA affordable-housing funding rules more flexible because current requirements may make projects harder to finance and create risks for the Los Angeles Housing Department.
However, under the likely upcoming socialist mayorship Los Angeles is likely to be enjoying shortly, the “Mansion Tax” will continue to be a rigid bureaucratic weapon of fiscal mass destruction.
Donations tax deductible
to the full extent allowed by law.





Comments
Run off the rich and tax who ever is left. When will Californians figure out the Democrat Party programs are killing them financially?
Never.
The problem is, the people that vote against such policies are the first to flee the State and never come back.
For D politicians, this is a feature, not a bug. Their goal is to remain in power forever, and driving out the political opposite is a very effective way of accomplishing that.
Its not that they don’t care that they are destroying the economy, its that destroying the economy is essential to their own personal power and prosperity. So, they do it on purpose.
The results are the same in every D run jurisdiction: The middle class is driven into poverty or flees, and what remains are the D elites and an ever growing class of government dependents that can be counted on to vote D in every election.
Income disparity, which D’s forever claim to be fighting against, is therefore at its very highest in jurisdictions that D’s have the most control over for the longest time.
Well said. I think there are a lot of people on our side who think the Democrats are cartoonishly malicious, doing evil for the sake of it. There are plenty who are ideological, granted, but the reality is that most Democrats are just crooks. Their goal is power and money for themselves and they say or do anything to get it. The key to permanent power is to create generations of vote cattle, animals that can be farmed every election to keep the (D) in power.
Useful Idiots
This a well written tragedy illustrating the collapse of our ‘check & balance” system. This vote should have been challenged when it was presented to the people because it is a democratic vote by a majority & is seen by many as good, but is actually unconstitutional. The citizens of LA live in a republic and the minority are (supposed to be) protected from tyranny by the majority. That’s the Founders definition of our republic, which is not a democracy but does contain minor elements of via voting…but it can not result in damaging the minority, the massion owners and, by extension of unintended consequences, the taxpayers of LA.
Which clause in the state or federal constitution do you claim it violates?
Maybe we should set up a Gofundme to help pay these taxes.
That’s something Newsom should do… if he ever did any actual work.
Hey, his morning toilet takes 3 hours.
“The 2023 tax has effectively blocked the building of 9,100 homes, wiped out 16,650 full-time construction jobs and cost $452 million in revenue.”
Whatever. Who cares. The tax will bring those capitalist pigs a lesson!
Somewhere, Atlas is starting to shrug.
Yes, this scenario has been replayed over and over again. Being a New Englander, my favorite example is GHW Bush’s “luxury yacht” tax that not only didn’t raise any additional revenue, but the resulting precipitous drop in yacht sales put out of business several northeastern boat builders including some that had been in business for over a hundred years.
It’s so funny that you mentioned the yacht tax.
I remember that so well how I drove the boat pills out of business and was almost immediately repealed.
Yet not one person mentioned that when they were contemplating in the mansion tax
It was Clinton that passed the yacht tax not Bush. There were 15 boat yards building yachts and high end fishing boats in Palm Beach County. Within 2 years all but 1 were closed as the orders dried up. Hundreds of workers out of a job. Local tax revenue down 4%.
Can you believe this jagoff trying to attribute a mindless tax to a Republican?
“a new transaction tax on any real estate sale over $5 million”
As usual, the libtard legislators inserted no provision for inflation, and the libtard voters were too stupid to realize that their own hovels would be trading at $5M or more within a decade.
Put that in your $100 burrito and eat it, you marching Marxist morons.
London high end property values are down 27% …
“London’s high-end housing market has been in the doldrums since then Chancellor of the Exchequer George Osborne kicked off a series of changes in 2014 that would significantly increase transaction taxes for the most expensive homes. Successive chancellors have since added surcharges on landlords and second home owners, overseas purchasers and those buying property through companies rather than in their own names.”
https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2026-10-05/luxury-london-homes-values-are-down-by-almost-half-in-real-terms
We can mostly expect the same from New York and LA experiments.
The UK is finished. They exterminated themselves. It began in the early 1900s with their version of gun control. Enjoy, subjects.
Our founding fathers had the right idea, limiting voting to property owners.
That would be property owning MEN to be exact.
I am all for going back to that standard.
And NO broads! The 18th Amendment was the beginning of the downfall of the republic.
I mean the 19th
I’ll drink to that!
/someone had to
Dems like to tax and are going after the money makers. These people generally are more liberal but know when it is time to leave and not support the Democrats. They easily sell and move to other states and locations.
And bring their failed liberal stupidity with them. Rinse, lather, etc. Soon there will be nowhere safe.
California fatigue. It is what it is.
I’m all for taxing Barbra Streisand into the poor house. Let her pay for her liberal nonsense.
I’m all for her being exterminated along with Jane Fondling and Bette Midler.
CA dems one party rule. They will double down on stupid. Brace yourself for more aggressive taxation.
well, I don’t know. it’s awfully pat to say mansion owners sold and moved out…but if they ‘sold,’ it means someone is buying.
what’s the answer to that little puzzle?