Image 01 Image 03

Study Finds Blue States With Strong Teacher Unions Have Lower Reading Scores

Study Finds Blue States With Strong Teacher Unions Have Lower Reading Scores

“Mississippi, Arkansas, Georgia, Louisiana, South Carolina and Indiana, all Republican-leaning states with weak unions, were among the states with the best literacy outcomes.”

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8ix9IkwjbUg

New analysis from the Progressive Policy Institute, hardly a conservative institution, has found that blue states with stronger teacher unions produce lower reading scores.

This reinforces what we have seen unfolding in Arkansas under Republican Governor Sarah Sanders, who has eschewed activism in favor of going back to the basics.

FOX News reports:

Powerful teachers’ unions share striking link with states struggling to teach kids to read

States with stronger teachers’ unions tend to have weaker literacy performance and have adopted fewer of the policies credited with improving reading outcomes, according to a new analysis from a center-left think tank.

Eight of the 10 states to score among the worst in the Progressive Policy Institute’s (PPI) assessment of early-literacy policies were home to powerful teachers’ unions. Among the top 60% of states in terms of early-literacy policy scores, only four had strong teachers’ unions.

Mississippi, Arkansas, Georgia, Louisiana, South Carolina and Indiana, all Republican-leaning states with weak unions, were among the states with the best literacy outcomes. Maine, New York, Illinois, Hawaii, Washington and Rhode Island, blue states, were among the worst.

The pattern isn’t universal. Maryland, a blue state with a strong teachers’ union, has posted strong reading results, while South Dakota, a red state with a weaker union, has struggled. The differences suggest union strength and party control alone don’t explain states’ reading performance.

More from the New York Post:

The assessment was conducted by the PPI’s Director of Education Policy, Rachel Canter, who spent nearly two decades in Mississippi advocating for systemic reforms, which transformed the state’s students from having among the lowest literacy rates in the nation to having some of the highest

And Canter’s study found one overwhelming and shocking throughline — the stronger the state’s teachers’ union the worse its student literacy scores were, results which did not exclusively follow party lines but strongly trended that way and often to the detriment of Democrats.

“Democrats, however, don’t often ask me how to replicate Mississippi’s success,” Canter said. “They ask if it’s possible at all, given the power of teachers’ unions in their home states.”

One reason for the disparity, Canter argued, is that states where teacher unions have a strong grip are slower to enact better programs.

She looked at 18 literacy policies recommended by ExcelinEd and found Democratic states had undertaken nine of them on average, while Republican and swing states had adopted an average of 13.5.

Democrats are usually seen as better on education, as an issue.

This story challenges that idea.

DONATE

Donations tax deductible
to the full extent allowed by law.

Comments

Now overlay these results with a comparable measure of welfare dependency, and throw in Indian reservations as a bonus. Then do a finer grid. Not states, but cities. Then neighborhoods.

“Study Finds Blue States With Strong Teacher Unions Have Lower Reading Scores”

That’s a feature, not a bug. IE: Public schools are not the best educational option for students. Public schools are permanent job programs for adults.

It’s your basic patronage system to cultivate loyal voters for the hand that feeds them.

It’s a system working as intended, and it must be destroyed. I have thoughts.

Thank you for coming to my ‘Draconian Solutions are your First, Best Solutions’ TED Talk.

What a ridiculous premise. Forget the automated teaching tools that let teachers be lazy, it’s actually the unions making kids stupid!

    Don’t mistake correlation for causation. The PPI’s report merely notes the general correlation of strong teachers’ unions with low reading scores and proposes a few potential explanations; it does not go so far as to say “strong unions cause illiteracy.”

    However, causation requires correlation, so the converse claim — that strong teachers’ unions are good for education — cannot be true.

    CommoChief in reply to rickcheese. | September 18, 2026 at 12:27 pm

    Members of teacher unions are often quick to blame poor outcomes on lack of accountability for Parents, students and ED policies while attempting to simultaneously side step any accountability for the low performing members of their union. When teacher unions begin demanding internal accountability and automatic firing for the bottom performing 5% of teachers annually those union’s credibility will skyrocket.

As a political and economic refugee from the Soviet Socialist State of Minnesota I find it sadly funny to see MN shown as a “swing state” in the graph.

While it’s true that everywhere outside of major metropolitan areas (Minneapolis, St. Paul, Rochester, Duluth) is generally conservative and Republican, the collectivist hordes of the non-productive that inhabit those cities drive almost 100% of the Marxist policies in the state.

Teaching is one of a very few professions* in which failure can be cited as justification for more funding and higher pay. Governments’ solution to all problems is always “more money.” Success doesn’t engender the same response. “You’re doing a fine job now. Why do you need more money?” This is how creating and maintaining problems works for teachers and their unions.

“Politics is the only other profession in this category that comes immediately to mind.

    Don’t forget, if the children lived in better housing they would do better in school.

    Teacher’s Union – basically a village idiot club

    As long as public schools are run by government, teaching and politics go hand-in-hand.

    Consider a private school: Failure is no longer justification for more funding and higher pay; it’s now a liability and a reason to pull funding and cancel endowments. Just like any other private business, low-performing employees face negative consequences.

    There’s good reason public-sector unions tend to be far more politically active — and politically liberal/Leftist — than private-sector ones.

Mississippi used to be a laughing stock but now it’s showing the way and the left can’t frickin stand it!

Gee – – Who’da thunk?