Critical audio gap in “complete” Romney tape released by Mother Jones (Update – Corn responds, 1-2 minutes missing)
Turns out tape cuts out part of controversial Romney answer
David Corn of Mother Jones released the “complete” audio and video of the secretly recorded Mitt Romney speech at a private fundraiser.
Yet the complete audio and video is not complete. There is a gap in the recording immediately after Romney’s now famous discussion of the 47% of voters who don’t pay taxes. The cut in the audio and video comes while Romney is in mid-sentence, so we actually do not have the full audio of what Romney said on the subject.
The next audio/video (Part 2) picks up with Romney talking about China.
I noticed this this afternoon and sent two tweets to Corn seeking an explanation.
I also sent Corn a Facebook message. I have yet to receive a response. I don’t have and can’t find Corn’s email address, or I would have done that also.
This audio/video from The Blaze shows the gap (via Moe Lane):
[Romney]“We do all these polls — I find it amazing. We poll all these people to see where you stand in the polls but 45 percent of the people vote for the Republicans and 48 or 49–,” This is where the first part of the video cuts out.
Part two picks up seemingly on a completely different subject: China.
“…about twice as much as China, not 10 times as much like is reported. And we have responsibility for the whole world, they’re only focused on one little area of the world, the south china sea…”
Something is missing. Romney’s 47% answer was cut off before completed, and is not picked up on the Part 2 audio video.
So the “complete” audio/video has not been released by Corn, or Corn never had it to begin with.
The explanation may be innocent, or the audio/video may be incomplete.
Given how various pundits have projected that the tape destroys Romney’s campaign, and the audio/video gap cuts off Romney’s highly publicized answer, I think we are entitled to the full audio/video, or an explanation of why we don’t have it.
Update: I found Corn’s email address, and he responded as follows:
According to the source, the recording device inadvertently turned off. The source noticed this quickly and turned it back one. The source estimates that one to two minutes, maybe less, of recording was missed.
Update 9-19-2012 – Maybe Romney answer was “inelegant” only because Mother Jones didn’t disclose that part of tape was missing
AND, see this blog post by a reader who says he’s not buying the source’s story about the recorder stopping then being restarted, Romney Tape Gap NOT Recording Error.










Comments
[…] Facebook, Twitter and email, Jacobson pressured Corn to explain the missing segment from the supposedly “full tape.” @DavidCornDC audio missing bet parts 1 and 2 of full […]
[…] Jones has now released the full audio recording — only it isn’t the full audio recording. Right after Romney makes his 47% remark, the audio skips to discussing China. David Corn of Mother […]
[…] a look here at a cornered David Corn of Mother Jones finally admitting that, yes indeed, Mother Jones has […]
[…] 9/19/2012: Then there is this, which just goes to underline that the Mitt Romney campaign ought to have its own independent audio […]
This.
Remember the advice to Sarah Palin after her interviews were edited?
It is obvious when going into a hostile interview — but probably did not occur to the Romney camp in a safe setting. But of course, everyone has phones that film and record now, so maybe there is an unedited copy out there?
Isn’t that how Obama’s bigoted comments in SF about the “bitter clingers” got out?
But then again — what was wrong with what Romney said –?
[…] Lie While Peddling Incomplete Romney Tape Posted on September 19, 2012 7:30 am by Bill Quick » Critical audio gap in “complete” Romney tape released by Mother Jones (Update – Corn respon… Something is missing. Romney’s 47% answer was cut off before completed, and is not picked […]
[…] from David Corn and Mother Jones brings us a new innovation — the triple standard. William Jacobson, Moe Lane, and The Blaze discovered that, contrary to claims made by Corn and MJ, the video […]
[…] blog Legal Insurrection was able to get a comment from David Corn, the reporter at Mother Jones peddling the videos, […]
[…] wjjhoge It turns out that that the “raw” video of the Romney 47 Percent speech has a couple of minutes missing, part of which is the remainder of his comments about Income Tax non-payers and Obama […]
[…] 19, 2012 | Filed under Mitt Romney | Posted by Doug JohnsonProfessor William Jacobson at Legal insurrection noticed that the “full and complete” secretly recorded video of Mitt Romney speaking to […]
[…] […]
[…] of the speech missing. Legal Insurrection’s William Jacobson first noticed the gap in the video last night: David Corn of Mother Jones released the “complete” audio and video of the secretly recorded […]
[…] There’s a gap in between the two videos posted. William Jacobson picked up on it and posted the videos at Legal Insurrection.Yet the complete audio and video is not complete. There is a gap in the recording immediately […]
Nobody even bothered to note that, once again, a lowly blogger has to do what should be the bare minimum expected of the MSM: ask for the unedited tape. A full time law professor finds a moment to do what never even occurred to thousands of full time “journalists.”
Kudos to the Professor for discovering the two-minute (or more) tape gap. The gap suggests that the tape might have been edited.
Why not have an audio expert check the tape carefully to see if the audio has been edited?
You might also have a lip-reader inspect the tape to see if Romney’s lip movements coincide with the audio.
[…] Never mind the tapes we hear dropped some 1-2 minutes from the presentation by Mother Jones (which constitutes selective editing). Never mind the MSM and the like-minded hacks were livid when they thought Breitbart did it. This is okay….. because it serves the purpose they are embracing, which is to get Obama re-elected at any cost. […]
[…] Blaze, is already causing some controversy on the right. The conservative blog Legal Insurrection sought Corn’s explanation and Joel Pollak, editor-in-chief of Breitbart.com, accused Mother Jones of breaking its promise […]
[…] Tuesday evening, Jacobson obtained the following comment from David Corn of Mother Jones: According to the source, the recording […]
[…] At least 2 minutes were chopped from the tape, likely by Mother Jones, who “discovered” it in the first place. And oh, by the way, James Carter IV, the unemployed, 35 year-old grandson of former president and abject failure Jimmy Carter, had a hand in the leaked video. […]
[…] Jacobsen asked Corn about the gap, and this is his explanation for it: According to the source, the recording device inadvertently turned off. The source noticed this […]
[…] 47% Romney “embarrassing” tape has a convenient “recording error” chopping out a couple of minutes right at the 47% junction. ::::cough:::: Rosemary Woods […]
[…] William Jacobson notices that the two YouTube videos representing Romney’s “complete speech” during the fundraiser have an audio break between them. He emailed David Corn of Mother Jones, who responded: According to the source, the recording device inadvertently turned off. The source noticed this quickly and turned it back one. The source estimates that one to two minutes, maybe less, of recording was missed. […]
Not too many people bought that excuse with Rosmary Woods, and the missing part of the Nixon tapes. I wonder how many people will buy it here.
[…] a look here at a cornered David Corn of Mother Jones finally admitting that, yes indeed, Mother Jones has […]
[…] Lady It’s About Liberty The Gateway Pundit Instapundit Left Bank of the Charles Hot Air Legal Insurrection The Volokh […]